History of Western Philosophy Renaissance and Enlightenment (2 of 2) – Reformation, Part 2

Clicking the green timestamps on the page automatically starts the audio player

About This Lecture

In Part 2 of this course at Christ College, Dr. Greg L. Bahnsen continues his examination of Western thought from the late Middle Ages through the Enlightenment, exploring the influence of the Reformation worldview on science and political development. He opens by considering the idea of science operating on “borrowed capital,” examining the contributions of Francis Bacon, Isaac Newton, and the Royal Society in the context of the Christian foundations of scientific inquiry.

Bahnsen then turns to the Reformation’s influence on the social and political order, particularly the conviction that kings themselves stand under the law of God. He traces the conflict between constitutionalism and absolutism through the Puritan Revolution, Parliament’s appeal to a higher law, the execution of Charles I, and the subsequent Stuart Restoration and Act of Conformity. He also compares the Puritan and French Revolutions, examining the contrasting foundations and aims of these movements.

The lecture concludes by considering the development of constitutionalism in New England, including the contributions of Samuel Rutherford and John Locke, and the problem of democracy detached from a higher law. Returning to the larger relationship between the Renaissance and Reformation, Bahnsen brings these historical developments into perspective, demonstrating how competing worldview commitments shape scientific inquiry, political authority, and the structure of society. His discussion offers presuppositional insights into the intellectual and social challenges that continue to confront our own day.

Table of Contents

  • Science and “Borrowed Capital”[00:00]
  • Bacon, Newton, and the Royal Society[01:02]
  • The Reformation’s Effects in the Socio-Political Realm[02:50]
  • The King Under the Law of God[06:04]
  • Constitutionalism versus Absolutism[09:51]
  • The Puritan Revolution[13:39]
  • Parliament Appeals to the Higher Law[18:20]
  • The Execution of Charles I[22:52]
  • The Stuart Restoration and the Act of Conformity[24:04]
  • The Puritan and French Revolutions Compared[25:46]
  • Constitutionalism in New England: Rutherford and Locke[26:14]
  • Democracy Without a Higher Law[28:38]
  • Reformation and Renaissance: The Big Picture[29:46]

Scripture References

TimestampReferenceWhat’s there
[01:02]Genesis 1:26–28; Genesis 3Allusion (inferred): Bahnsen relays Schaeffer’s quotation of Francis Bacon on man’s fall from innocence and from dominion over creation, and on the partial repair of those losses. The Genesis passages are inferred from the fall and dominion language; Bahnsen does not cite them. He adds that he would not agree with everything Bacon taught.
[29:46]John 14:6Allusion (inferred): Recapping the ancient world, Bahnsen says that in the midst of pagan darkness the way, the truth, and the life, Jesus, brings the church’s view of the world and of man, different from the pagans’. John 14:6 is inferred from the wording; he gives no citation.
[29:46]Acts 17Allusion (inferred): Bahnsen points to the conflict at Mars Hill as the philosophical expression of the antithesis between the early church and pagan humanism. He names the place, not the passage; Acts 17 is inferred.

Explore This Lecture Further

These study aids organize and summarize what Dr. Bahnsen says in this lecture. They are not his words, and they add no outside background. Much of the lecture is Bahnsen working through a chapter by Schaeffer, so the tables mark whose point is whose wherever the transcript allows. Each timestamp jumps to the start of the transcript paragraph where the point is made, so the audio may begin slightly before it.

Science and “Borrowed Capital”: Bahnsen’s Argument

Bahnsen is explaining an argument from Schaeffer’s chapter. This is a summary of how that argument runs in the lecture.

  1. Schaeffer’s point, as Bahnsen explains it, does not mean that only Christians can do science. Non-Christians can do it successfully. [00:00]
  2. Yet when they succeed, they cannot explain why the world is open to study, experimentation, and generalization. [00:00]
  3. To study nature scientifically, one must believe it is characterized by regularity. [00:26]
  4. Bahnsen says the Christian worldview can account for that regularity, through God’s sovereignty and his covenants. [00:26]
  5. The non-Christian does not want that theology, so he does the science without giving an account of it. Bahnsen says such people are “living on borrowed capital,” using the Christian philosophy of life while denying it. [00:00] [00:26]

The examples Bahnsen reports from the chapter:

  • Francis Bacon. Bahnsen says he “could be called the major prophet of the scientific revolution” and took the Bible seriously. Schaeffer quotes Bacon’s Novum Organum (1620) on the fall and on the partial repair of man’s lost dominion over creation by the arts and sciences. Bahnsen says he would not agree with everything Bacon taught, but Bacon was thinking in terms of a Christian worldview: man is not autonomous, has a relationship to God, and works in God’s world. [01:02]
  • Isaac Newton. Described as the climax of the scientific revolution. Bahnsen mentions Newton’s Christianity and his conception that God created the universe, which is why it is subject to mathematical formulation. [01:45]
  • The Royal Society. Schaeffer points out that many members of the Royal Society for the Improving of Natural Knowledge were professing Christians who saw their work as a display of the truth of Christianity. [01:45]
  • Pascal and Descartes. Named in the same passage. Bahnsen says the class will look at Descartes soon, but not that day. [01:45]
  • Einstein. Schaeffer says that even in modern physics, the relativity asserted does not give up the notion of a universal order. Bahnsen says they will talk more about that later. [02:23]

What the lecture does not claim: Bahnsen says outright that this does not mean only Christians can do science [00:00], and that he would not endorse everything Bacon taught [01:02].

Schaeffer and Bahnsen: Whose Voice Is Whose

A summary table. The middle column is Bahnsen reporting Schaeffer’s points; the right column is Bahnsen’s own agreement, disagreement, or addition.

TimestampTopicReported from SchaefferBahnsen’s own addition or judgment
[01:02]BaconBacon took the Bible seriously, and wrote that the fall cost man his innocence and his dominion over creation, both partly repairable (the first by religion and faith, the second by the arts and sciences).Bahnsen would not agree with everything Bacon taught, but says Bacon was nevertheless thinking in terms of a Christian worldview.
[03:16] [04:22] [05:31]Political freedomWith Rome’s authority broken, Protestantism brings progressive political freedom. A consensus on biblical absolutes lets a society have freedom without anarchy. Freedom asserted outside a biblical worldview degenerates into anarchy and license, then into greater state tyranny, and back and forth.Bahnsen applies it to the Puritans: God has revealed how we are to live together, so the state has no right to assert authority in addition to God, just as the church had none.
[07:15]Limits of the claimSchaeffer says he is not claiming that everything connected with Reformed Christianity in socio-political reform was pure and correct.Bahnsen is not sure he would follow everything Schaeffer says, and thinks Schaeffer may not have understood the slavery issue in America as well as he might. He wants the Puritans given more respect, but disagrees with some of what they did, such as price controls in Puritan New England.
[08:31]The Bible as a base for lawThe Bible gives a base for law.Bahnsen agrees. Our laws are not worded as the Bible words them, but the principles taught in the Bible are the foundation for our civil codes.
[08:59]Justice and VinetPoints to Paul Robert’s painting Justice Lifts the Nations, in which justice directs rulers to the law of God, and quotes Vinet that Christianity is the immortal seed of the freedom of the world.Bahnsen gives two reasons: Christianity broke the stranglehold of Rome, and it gave a foundation for living together in civil order while granting freedom to citizens.
[26:14]Rulers under God’s lawThe Reformation insisted on the responsibility of all people, even monarchs, through the law of God: a government of law rather than arbitrary decisions of men.Bahnsen says the Puritans in what will become the United States have a foundation for constitutionalism, viewing the law of God as above the civil government.
[27:00] [27:32]LockeLocke’s idea of civil government was a secularization of the Presbyterian tradition he would have known.Bahnsen says Schaeffer is “exactly right,” adds that Locke lived through the Puritan Revolution, and then offers his own criticism of Locke’s empiricism.
[28:38]DemocracyDemocracy as majority vote can create its own despotism. (Bahnsen says he will only summarize this, because the class is reading it.)Bahnsen spells out the danger: without the Christian worldview, the majority can beat up the minority without restraint, because law is just what the majority says.

Under God’s Law or Above It: Positions Compared

The starting point is a parallel Bahnsen draws. The Puritans understood that the state has no right to assert authority in addition to God, just as the church has no right to [05:31]. If churchmen must be subject to Scripture, the king must observe the law of God too [06:04]. This table summarizes the positions the lecture contrasts.

TimestampPositionHow the lecture describes itWhat follows for freedom and for appeal
[10:28] [11:15] [13:02]The king under the law of God (constitutionalism)Bahnsen says the Reformers held that all princes are subject to law and must rule in a constitutional fashion. As God gives a law that makes our living predictable, the king must deliver a law by which people can calculate how to live and can hold him accountable. This was taught by Bucer, Calvin, and especially the Presbyterian Puritans of England and New England.Freedom from arbitrary government is freedom under the law of God. When the king interferes where God does not allow it, that is tyranny. God’s law also provides a constitution of appeal: one appeals to the higher law against the law of the magistrate.
[09:51] [10:28] [12:08]AbsolutismSchaeffer sets constitutionalism over against the absolutism of the late medieval view of civil rule. Bahnsen says that if you separate your political view from Scripture, you finally have order in the state only through absolutism, the supreme authority of the prince. (He says he is going to “overgeneralize.”) He cites Hobbes: the Leviathan must exercise his freedom and make everybody submit, and if that means oppression, so be it.The ruler is not limited by anything above him.
[12:08] [13:02]Freedom with no higher lawBahnsen says that if freedom is not freedom under a higher law, then the king is free also, and what limits freedom is simply the limits of power. You cannot found freedom in freedom itself.With the higher law eliminated, there is only the law of the magistrate and no appeal beyond it. If the magistrate is a tyrant, the one remedy left is revolution, which Bahnsen calls the French solution.
[28:38] [29:26]Democracy without a higher lawBahnsen says that without the Christian worldview, democracy as majority vote can become its own despotism, because law is just what the majority says. He contrasts the despotism of the Leviathan, one man imposing his law, with the despotism of the majority.To avoid tyranny, or what he calls gangsterism, and then anarchy, society needs a law over all of it that creates its political institutions, guides them, and restricts them.

The Puritan Revolution: Events and Bahnsen’s Evaluations

A summary of the events in the order Bahnsen tells them. He gives only a few dates, and this list adds none. Where the right column is empty, he gives no evaluation in that passage.

TimestampWhat Bahnsen describesHis evaluation, where he gives one
[14:07]Henry VIII throws off the authority of Rome, and Parliament declares the king head and chief of the church in England as well as the state. Succession then raises the question whether the ruler will favor Rome (Mary) or the Protestant cause (Edward). [14:41]Bahnsen says Henry acted not to reform Rome’s theology but because Rome would not give him his way: “power versus power,” with no higher appeal and no justice.
[15:18]In the 1600s Charles comes to the throne, sympathetic to the Roman cause and to Episcopalian government, and appoints Laud as his archbishop. The people suffer under two tyrannical courts, the Star Chamber and the High Commission. The Puritans are persecuted.Bahnsen calls the courts tyrannical and says the Puritans, who were trying to bring the word of God to the people of England, were not favored.
[15:43] [16:09]Many persecuted Puritans go to a new wilderness and start over.Bahnsen says it was a terrible thing, but in God’s providence it is the beginning of America as we know it: the New England colonies.
[16:34]Charles disbands Parliament and rules without it for eleven years.Bahnsen remarks that this is hardly a modern democratic ruler.
[16:51]Charles holds to the divine right of kings and insists that without a bishop in the church he could not have a king in the state. He imposes his form of church government on Scotland, where the Scots, heirs of John Knox’s labor for Presbyterian government, refuse it. Jenny Geddes throws her stool at the bishop bringing a new prayer book. The Scots go to war with him.Bahnsen tells it as an ironic history: these Scots will be allies of Charles in a few years.
[18:09] [18:20]To fund the war Charles needs a tax, so he recalls Parliament. The Puritans largely control it and present grievances. They refuse taxes until he corrects the abuses, and he dismisses Parliament again: the Short Parliament.Bahnsen says the Puritans are appealing to “the law above the law.”
[18:54]In 1640 Charles must call Parliament back: the Long Parliament. It forbids the king to dissolve it. Civil war follows, and Charles flees. Under Parliament’s authority the Puritans commission learned divines to reform the Church of England, which produces the Westminster Assembly and eventually the Westminster Confession.
[20:07]Oliver Cromwell takes command of the army, and the Puritans enter a solemn league and covenant with the Scots requiring Presbyterian church government throughout the United Kingdom.Bahnsen credits Cromwell as a “brilliant field strategist,” and says that is all he will give him.
[20:37]The king is routed. The Westminster standards are adopted in Scotland, but the English adopt them only in amended form and do not adopt Presbyterianism.Bahnsen asks whether that sounds like covenant breaking, and says it does to him.
[21:02]Charles allies with the Scots he once fought. Scotland goes to war against Cromwell, who defeats them and has no sympathy for the Presbyterians.
[21:53]Cromwell establishes a protectorate. He is Lord Protector for life, with hereditary succession.Bahnsen respects Cromwell as a general, but says one ultimate tyranny has been replaced by another. One was called a king, the other a protector, but they are the same in function.
[22:28]When Parliament does not give Cromwell his way, he marches the army in and removes the Presbyterians.Bahnsen asks whether this is “ruling by right” or “ruling by might.” We are back to the king and the tyranny.
[22:52] [23:18] [23:37]Bahnsen then turns to the fate of Charles, whom the Puritans executed. He introduces it “in the midst of all this,” so he tells it after the protectorate and the removal of the Presbyterians. Critics call the Puritans “king killers.”Bahnsen says that, although he does not like Cromwell’s tyranny, Cromwell and the Puritans had the right to execute the king, because the king is not above the law. His reasoning: conspiring to murder carries the penalty of death, and the king conspired to have his own citizens killed in war and went to a foreign country to help him attack his own people.
[24:04] [24:57]Charles II, who had fled to France, is restored. The Stuart monarchy returns, and in 1662 he passes the Act of Conformity. The Presbyterians whom Cromwell had marched out of Parliament are now removed from their pulpits.
[25:26]Bahnsen sums up his view of the revolution.He says he has great disdain for the Stuart monarchy and for Cromwell as well. Cromwell’s independency, pride, and self-centeredness created another tyranny, and the Puritan Revolution was lost.

The Puritan and French Revolutions Compared

A summary. Bahnsen makes this comparison in a short passage, and in this lecture he does not discuss events or thinkers of the French Revolution.

TimestampQuestionThe Puritan RevolutionThe French Revolution
[13:02] [13:39]Recourse against a tyrantBahnsen says the Puritans were not stuck with revolution as the only remedy. They could appeal to a higher law.With no higher law, the only thing left to do about a tyrant is to have a revolution. Bahnsen calls this the French solution.
[25:46]Relation to a higher lawThe Puritans were appealing to a law that permitted them to judge the king.In France a higher law is totally thrown out.
[25:26] [25:46]What followedBahnsen says the Puritan Revolution was lost and another tyranny arose, though the principles of Puritan political theory find expression in New England [26:14].Eventually, he says, what you have is just anarchy, every man for himself.

Rutherford, Witherspoon, and Locke

A summary of the passage that follows the New England discussion. The right column says whose claim each row reports, as far as the transcript shows.

TimestampFigure or topicWhat the lecture saysWhose claim
[26:14]Puritans in New EnglandBahnsen says the principles of Puritan political theory come to expression in New England, giving a foundation for constitutionalism, with the law of God viewed as above the civil government.Bahnsen, followed by a point from Schaeffer
[27:00]Samuel Rutherford and John WitherspoonRutherford’s “Lex Rex, The Law is King” was very influential on the writing of the U.S. Constitution via the Presbyterian churchman John Witherspoon.Stated by Bahnsen as he reports what Schaeffer examines. The transcript does not separate the two.
[27:00]John LockeLocke lived through the Puritan Revolution. His idea of civil government was “a secularization of the Presbyterian tradition” he would have been familiar with.Schaeffer’s claim. Bahnsen says Schaeffer is “exactly right.”
[27:32]Problems in LockeLocke holds an empirical view, that we know everything by our senses, and also holds to natural rights. But through the senses we cannot find anything about rights or wrongs in nature, so Locke cannot make sense of his political philosophy in terms of the empiricism he advances.Bahnsen’s own criticism
[27:56]Where Locke got itBahnsen says Locke got it from the Presbyterian tradition. The Bible provides a foundation for inalienable rights, which are found in nature’s God rather than in nature, and for government by consent, a separation of powers, and “the right of revolution.” Bahnsen explains that phrase as a covenantal lawsuit against a king who has himself rebelled against the law and tyrannized the people.Bahnsen, with Schaeffer’s phrase for the last right

Reformation and Renaissance: Bahnsen’s Big Picture

This is a framework Bahnsen states himself as he recaps the course. He says he is giving the overall picture ([30:42]) and admits he is “overdrawing” it ([31:11]).

TimestampPeriodBahnsen’s labelWhat he says
[29:46]Ancient worldPaganismThe ancient world expressed pagan philosophy.
[29:46] [30:42]Early churchAntithesisJesus and the church promote a view of the world and of man different from the pagans’. Bahnsen sees the conflict philosophically at Mars Hill and politically in “the beast of Rome” persecuting Christians.
[30:42] [31:11]Middle AgesSynthesisAn attempt to bring a little paganism and a little Christianity together in a fruitful union. It ends in a dichotomy: faith and theology in one domain, philosophy, reason, and science in another.
[29:46] [31:11]RenaissanceThe “Renaissance of Humanism”It picks up the seed of that dichotomy and runs with it, reviving paganism through the classics of Greek pagan philosophy.
[29:46] [31:46]ReformationThe “Reformation of Christianity”The formal parallel to the Renaissance. It wants to revive the original Christianity, which begins a new period of antithesis. Bahnsen believes we are living at the end of it.

Key People and Institutions

Only what Bahnsen says about each person or body. Bacon, Newton, the Royal Society, Pascal, Descartes, and Einstein appear under Borrowed Capital above. Rutherford, Witherspoon, and Locke appear in their own section.

TimestampPerson or institutionWhat Bahnsen says
[00:00] [07:15]SchaefferThe author whose chapter Bahnsen works through. Bahnsen agrees with him at points and at others says he would not follow him.
[14:07]Henry VIIIThrew off Rome’s authority because Rome would not give him his way, not to reform its theology.
[14:41]Mary and EdwardExamples of rulers sympathetic to Rome (Mary) and to the Protestant cause (Edward).
[15:18] [16:51]Charles ISympathetic to Rome and Episcopalian government. Ruled without Parliament for eleven years, held the divine right of kings, and fought the Scots over church government. Executed by the Puritans, which Bahnsen says they had the right to do ([23:18]).
[15:18]LaudAppointed archbishop by Charles.
[16:51]John Knox and Jenny GeddesKnox had not labored in vain to establish Presbyterian government in Scotland. Geddes threw her stool at the bishop who came with a new prayer book.
[20:07] [21:53] [22:28]Oliver CromwellA brilliant field strategist and later Lord Protector for life, who marched the army into Parliament. Bahnsen dislikes his tyranny but affirms the right to execute the king.
[24:04] [24:57]Charles IIFled to France, was restored with the Stuart monarchy, and passed the Act of Conformity in 1662.
[12:08] [24:28]Thomas HobbesAuthor of Leviathan. Bahnsen says Hobbes is explicit that the Leviathan must make everybody submit, and that in his political philosophy religious dissent should be violently put down. Bahnsen presents him as Charles II’s tutor in France, and defers fuller treatment to the next session.
[11:15]Bucer and CalvinTaught that the king is not above the law.
[09:51] [10:28]Dante, Marsiglio, Bodin, MachiavelliBahnsen says Dante gives the separation of church and state, both subject to God. He names Marsiglio, Bodin, and Machiavelli in a question, and the point that follows is that political theory separated from Scripture ends in absolutism.
[14:07] [18:54]ParliamentDeclares the king head of the church under Henry. Under Charles it is dissolved, recalled as the Short Parliament, then the Long Parliament, which forbids its own dissolution.
[15:18]Star Chamber and High CommissionThe two courts under which the English people suffered.
[18:54] [20:37]Westminster AssemblyLearned divines called to reform the Church of England in doctrine, government, and laws, which eventually wrote the Westminster Confession. Its standards were adopted in Scotland and only in amended form in England.
[20:07]Solemn League and CovenantAn agreement between the Puritans and the Scots requiring Presbyterian church government throughout the United Kingdom.

Full Transcript

[00:00] On the next page, Schaeffer explains, this does not mean that it’s only Christians who can do science, but when non-Christians do science and are successful at it, they cannot give an account of their success. They cannot explain why the world is amenable to the study, experimentation, and generalizations that they have, and therefore, when non-Christians do science successfully, they are philosophically living on borrowed capital.

[00:26] That is, they’re really using our philosophy of life, all the while denying the, if you will, as I was saying, non-Christians, in order to study the natural world scientifically, must believe that it’s characterized by regularity, and the Christian worldview can account for that regularity because of God’s sovereignty and his covenants and so forth, but the non-Christian doesn’t want God, doesn’t want this theology you’ve brought into the picture. So, they go ahead and do their science, but they can’t give an account of the science and the success that they are pursuing.

[01:02] At the bottom of page 134, Schaeffer points out that Francis Bacon, who could be called the major prophet of the scientific revolution, took the Bible seriously. And then he quotes from Novum Organum, 1620. Man, by the fall, fell at the same time from his state of innocence and from his dominion over creation. Both of these losses, however, can even in this life be in some parts repaired, the former by religion and faith, the latter by the arts and sciences. And Schaeffer points out, we don’t have to agree with all that Francis Bacon taught, I wouldn’t, but he nevertheless was thinking in terms of a Christian worldview. Man is not autonomous here. He has a relationship to God. He works in God’s world.

[01:45] Or you think about the work of Sir Isaac Newton, the climax of the scientific revolution, and Newton’s Christianity and his conception that God had created the universe, and that’s why it was subject to mathematical formulation and so forth. He looks at Blaise Pascal, Rene Descartes, we’ll be looking at Descartes soon, not today. And then at the bottom of page 136, he points out that many members of the Royal Society for the Improving of Natural Knowledge were professing Christians, and they saw their work as a display of the truth of Christianity.

[02:23] Well, you can go on to read the rest of the chapter. He gets a bit beyond our age, and he comes up to talk about Einstein and the idea that what we’ve really gotten away from that Newtonian universe that we are now calling a Christian expression. And he points out that even in modern physics, the relativity that is asserted is not the relativity that gives up the notion of a universal order. And we’ll talk more about that later.

[02:50] But I wanted you to see the effects of the Reformation are not only with respect to man and nature and philosophy. There are effects of the Reformation in the scientific revolution. And then finally, there are effects of Reformation in the socio-political realm as well. And so let’s talk about political reform as part of the Reformation and its significance in the history of man and his thinking.

[03:16] Schaeffer points to the result of the Reformation in the socio-political realm in indicating that with the breakdown of the authority of the Roman Catholic Church, we have not only Protestant churches that spring up, But we also see a breakdown of the political stranglehold of Rome, and with Protestantism then comes the progressive freedom of the Western nations and world, the kind of freedom that we think of today as political freedom. The return to biblical Christianity gradually brought forth, Schaeffer says, political freedom, because there was a consensus among men, a general consensus among men, based on biblical absolutes. If you begin with the Bible, sola scriptura, and that our only hope of being right with God is through the marriage of His Son, and that we are now directed by His revelation, not only as to how to understand the world, but live in the world and live together in the world.

[04:22] If there’s a consensus based on biblical absolutes, then Schaeffer says society has the opportunity for tremendous freedom without running into anarchy and chaos, and he maintains that the freedom we’re talking about here is unique to the lands of the Reformation, that where political freedom is asserted outside of the framework of a biblical world and life view, with that consensus of moral absolutes, political freedom always degenerates into anarchy and license. And then what happens is to, if you will, counterbalance that anarchy. Political orders then run to a greater tyranny, an emphasis upon the law and order of the state. And that becomes oppressive, and people cry out against it, and they move back more toward a revolutionary, anarchistic approach. And then that creates problems, and they go back. And constantly you have this back and forth between the authority of the state, the freedom of its citizens.

[05:31] But they didn’t have that, for instance, among the Puritans. Because the Puritans understood that God has revealed how we’re to live together. And the state has no right to assert its authority in addition to God. Now does that sound familiar? They’re ringing in your ears. We said to the church, you have no right to assert your authority in addition to God’s. What did I tell you? The Roman Catholic Church had taken the authority of God’s word and then exalted the authority of the church equal to it.

[06:04] Well, it shouldn’t surprise us then that people who are consistently reformational in their outlook would say, you know what? That’s what the king’s doing too. Because he’s going far beyond what God allows him to do in his law. law. And so the king must observe the law of God, just like churchmen must be subject to the scripture. And if we’re going to have freedom in the church, God’s freedom, we’re going to have freedom in the state, God’s freedom, not just license, then we need to have the word of God as the foundation of our political order, as well as the foundation of our church. And by the way, You see, these Puritans were, to use the term of derision today, Biblicists.

[06:51] They had the audacity to think that the Bible is authoritative in all areas of life. And they also believed that the Bible, either in particular or in general, spoke to every area of life. And so the result of the Reformation is perhaps most dramatically seen in the kind of political reform efforts that rise out of it.

[07:15] Schaeffer tells us in this chapter, I’m not sure that I’d follow everything he had to say, I don’t think he has understood the slavery issue in our country as well as he might and so forth, but details aside, Schaeffer points out we are not claiming that everything that’s connected with reformed Christianity in terms of sociopolitical reform was pure and correct, you know. I happen to be somebody today that wants to see the Puritans given more respect. I think they had something going for them. But I don’t agree with everything the Puritans did. They had an experiment with price controls in Puritan New England, which they should not have done if they understood the Bible and applied it more consistently. So no one at this point is trying to say, look at all the details of Reformed or Puritan Christianity, and that’s, of course, what we do.

[08:08] That would be another form of traditionalism that Reformed theology doesn’t allow to us, does it? We don’t follow tradition. We aim to follow the Word of God. But I want you to see and have respect for the fact that when people followed the Word of God in the days of the Reformation, that didn’t simply mean in the church. That meant in the state as well. And therefore, they reformed their political orders.

[08:31] And so Schaeffer tells us, it is the Bible which gives a base for law. And I agree with you, our socio-political laws, I think, are based in the Bible. They may not be worded exactly as we read in the Bible, we don’t talk about flying axe heads and so forth, but the principles that are taught in the Bible are the foundation for our civil codes.

[08:59] And so Schaeffer points to the painting by Paul Robert, Justice Lifts the Nations, isn’t a beautiful idea? There’s justice with her sword extended, and what does justice point to to direct the rulers of the nation? The law of God, that’s right, the word of God. Schaeffer quotes the Swissman Vinet, Christianity is the immortal seed of the freedom of the world. You see, and that for two reasons that are often not appreciated. Because Christianity provided the way to break the stranglehold of Rome, but also provided a foundation for men to live together in civil order and yet granting freedom to the citizens of any land.

[09:51] And then Schaeffer points to constitutionalism as the development of reformed political theory over against the absolutism of the late medieval view of civil rule. Now, we looked at the late Middle Ages and the beginning of the Renaissance with respect to political theory, didn’t we? And we get in Dante, for instance, the separation of church and state, both subject to the authority of God. That looks, you know, pretty Protestant. That’s pretty good. How about Marsiglio, Bodin, Machiavelli?

[10:28] What happens if you take your political view and separate it from Scripture is that you finally have order in the state only by having absolutism. You have the supreme authority of the prince. Well, I’m going to overgeneralize, but I want to get to the point here. What the Reformers said is all princes are subject to law. They are not above the law. And they must rule in a constitutional fashion, even as God delivers a law which makes our living predictable and guides us, so the king must deliver a law by which we can calculate how to live, we can predict, and we can hold him accountable as well.

[11:15] The king is not above the law. So declared Bucer, Calvin, and especially the Presbyterian Puritans of England and New England. They all taught a principle of political limitation. We are to be free from arbitrary government power, free from the restriction of our expressing our Christian views and so forth. But the way in which we gain this freedom is not by saying everybody can do whatever they want. But by pointing out that the king is subject to the law of God, and therefore when God doesn’t allow the king to interfere in our lives, then that’s tyranny. Our freedom of expression, our freedom from arbitrary government, is freedom under the law of God.

[12:08] And this is not a course in political ethics, and so I can’t go on and on as I might have a desire to do. but in seed form, let me just point out to you that the reformers are right in terms of their political theory because if you say freedom is not freedom under a higher law, then as a matter of fact, the king is free also, isn’t he? And if everybody’s free, then what limits freedom is simply the limits of power. And it won’t be today as I had thought, but tomorrow when we compare Calvin to Hobbes, Hobbes explicitly says that. The Leviathan has got to exercise his freedom and make everybody submit to him. If that means oppression, so be it. You can’t found freedom in freedom itself. Freedom is found under the law of God.

[13:02] So, what happens is, when you want to complain against the alleged tyranny of your political leader, the law of God provides that constitution, if you will, of appeal. So, you appeal to the higher law against the law of the magistrate. But if there’s no higher law, then what do you have left? Eliminate this, you only have the law of the magistrate. Well, there can’t be any appeal beyond the law of the magistrate, so if the magistrate happens to be a tyrant, what can you do about it? There’s only one thing you can do, and this is, of course, the French solution, and that’s to have a revolution.

[13:39] The Puritans, however, were not stuck with that, and I’d like to illustrate that, the principle of political limitation, a higher law, from the history of the Puritan revolution. Many of us will not be familiar with the details of the Puritan Revolution, but it’s very significant in Western history. To understand it, we should really go all the way back to King Henry VIII. He’s not up on the board anymore, but you remember where he was in our timeline.

[14:07] Henry VIII wanted to get rid of the authority of Rome, but not because he was interested in reforming the theology and the corruptions of Rome, but because Rome wouldn’t give him his way. So here you have a classic modern problem, power versus power. There’s no higher appeal here, there’s no justice, it’s just who can have his way. So you have Henry throwing off the authority of Rome and the parliament declaring that the king is the head and chief of the church in England as well as in the state in England.

[14:41] Well, when Henry dies, there’s a number of problems as to who’s going to take the throne, and especially whether the one who takes the throne is going to be sympathetic to the Protestant cause or to the Roman Catholic. Well, the English church is supposed to be neither, okay? But it can’t be neither because these are logically, you know, distinct possibilities. And so it turns out that you have those who are sympathizers with Rome, like Mary, and those who are more sympathetic to the Protestant cause, like Edward. But nevertheless, you have the history of English rulers.

[15:18] We come into the 1600s, and Charles comes to the throne, who is distinctly sympathetic to the Roman cause, to Episcopalian government, and he appoints Laud as his archbishop. And the people in England begin to suffer under two tyrannical courts, the Star Chamber and the State of the High Commission of the Church. The Puritans in particular are hated by law.

[15:43] The man who commissioned a translation of the English Bible known as the King James Bible once said, I don’t care a turd for the Puritans. So these Puritans who were attempting to reform the church and the state, to bring the word of God to the people of England, were not favored by the high command in England. And they were persecuted.

[16:09] And what happened? when many who were persecuted decided they would go to a new wilderness and start over again. And though that was a terrible thing that happened to them in the providence of God, I praise him, that’s the beginning of America as we know it, really. The foundation of the New England colonies and so forth. And that’s another story. I love it so I have to be careful not to get older. Back to old England now.

[16:34] So here you have these persecuting powers in the church and in the state against the Puritans, Charles disbanded the parliament and dared to rule without it for eleven years. Not really your ideal of a modern democratic ruler, huh?

[16:51] He believed in the divine right of kings, he believed in the right of succession of his authority to his family, and he believed that if he did not have a bishop in the church, he could not have a king in the state, and therefore he insisted on the imposition of high fiscal form of government not only in England which had come about from Henry but now in Scotland as well that he found the Scots not to be an easy people to deal with this way and they would have none of it they have the you know the wonderful story of Jenny Geddes who throws her stool at the bishop when he comes with a new prayer book you know to be imposed on the Scottish church. John Knox had not labored in vain to establish a Presbyterian form of government in Scotland. The Scots were not easily put off with what Charles was doing. And so they go to war with him. Now I want you to listen closely because they’re going to end up being allies of Charles in a few years. Yes, I know it’s one of those ironic histories, but here’s how it works. Well, the Scots go to war with Charles and And Charles finds, to his distress, to prosecute a war, you need money.

[18:09] And the only way he can raise money is by having the Parliament impose a tax. And so he calls the Parliament back into session. He’s ruled without the Parliament for over a decade, but now he wants the Parliament.

[18:20] Well, lo and behold, as he calls the Parliament back into session, the Puritans are pretty much in control of the Parliamentary Assembly, and so they address a series of grievances to Charles. Okay? What are they doing? They’re appealing to the law above the law, saying, Charles, you’re wrong, and we want you to correct these things. Well, he’s incensed. They won’t give taxes until he corrects the abuses, and so he dismisses the parliament again, and that’s why it’s called the short parliament. Only a few months, and he says, okay, away with you.

[18:54] Problem is, the war effort didn’t get any better, and in 1640, he was forced to call parliament back into session. this now called the Long Parliament. The Long Parliament, because one of the first things they did is they passed the law forbidding the king to dissolve the Parliament. Okay. When Charles still doesn’t get his way, eventually the Parliament and the king go to war with each other. There’s civil war in England, and Charles has to flee. And in the absence of the king, under the authority of the long parliament, the Puritans pass a law, actually a commission, to call for the most learned divines throughout the empire to come together and reform the Church of England with respect to its doctrine and especially its government and laws. And this is what we know as the Westminster Confession, that Westminster Assembly, which wrote eventually the Westminster Confession. And so the Puritan party, the parliamentary party, is at war with the king and the royalists, and the Puritans are not doing very well.

[20:07] So two things turn the tide for the Puritans. One, Oliver Cromwell comes to take command of the army, who was a brilliant field strategist. Got to give that to him, nothing else. And they entered into a solemn league and covenant with the Scots. Now, the solemn league and covenant required that Presbyterians would be the government of the church in all of, you know, the United Kingdom.

[20:37] Eventually, the king was routed. The Westminster Assembly was finished. The Presbyterian form of government and the standards of the Westminster Confession were adopted in Scotland. But the English would only adopt them in amended form and would not adopt the Presbyterianism. Does it sound like covenant breaking to you? It does to me.

[21:02] When Charles sees that there’s trouble between the Presbyterian and the Independent in the Puritan party, he thinks this is his opportunity to come back and reassert his rule. So knowing that the Presbyterians are willing to have the king come back and rule, but under now the constitution and with Presbyterianism, excuse me, now under the limitations that the parliament would put on him and so forth, he goes to the Scots, whom he originally warred with, and enters into an alliance. So now Scotland goes to war with the king against Cromwell. Cromwell slaughters him. Cromwell does not have a great deal of sympathy for these Presbyterians who would dare to go into some kind of league with the king.

[21:53] And so now Cromwell establishes a protectorate in England. He is the Lord Protector for life, and succession in the protectorate is going to be hereditary. Now I know many people who have a respect for Cromwell as a general. And I appreciate that and what he accomplished. But don’t you see, in the case of Cromwell, what we have is the replacement of one ultimate tyranny with another ultimate tyranny. One was called a king, the other was called a protector, but they’re really the same in function.

[22:28] Cromwell, having no sympathy for the Presbyterians, when he didn’t get his way from Parliament, marched the army into Parliament and removed the Presbyterians. Is this ruling by a higher law, ruling by right, or is this ruling by might? You see, in Cromwell, we just go 180 and then 180 again, we’re right back to having the king and the tyranny all over again.

[22:52] Now, in the midst of all this, finally, let me pose the question. What should have been done with Charles? The king has been captured. How should the Puritans deal with him? And many people throughout history will keep abuse upon the Puritans because they executed Charles. Thereafter became known as king killers. How could they do such a terrible thing?

[23:18] Even though I don’t happen to like Cromwell in terms of his tyranny and all the rest, I do agree that Cromwell and the Puritans with him had the right to execute the king. Why? Because of this principle of political limitation. The king is not above the law.

[23:37] What is the penalty for conspiring to murder? Death. The king conspired to have his own constituents, his own citizens, killed in war. He was guilty of treason going to a foreign country to encourage it, to help him attack his own people so that he can be put back on the throne. The Puritans saw that logic, they found him guilty, and they executed him.

[24:04] Well, it’d be nice if that were the end of the story, and then we have the Puritan reign thereafter, but the problem is we already have the protectorate of Cromwell. Well, now, who’s waiting in the wings to take over England? Charles II, Prince of Wales, has fled to France, knowing that his own father has been executed, and who, by the way, is a tutor, Charles II, in France.

[24:28] Thomas Hobbes, who writes Leviathan, Leviathan the Beast, and tomorrow we’ll see, it was going to be today, we don’t have time, tomorrow we’ll see that in Hobbes’ political philosophy, religious dissent should be violently put down. You extricate your opponents. Well, not that you should think his student was unmindful of this view.

[24:57] When Charles II does come back from Cromwell and is reinstituted, the monarchy, the Stuart Monarchy is reinstituted, in 1662 he passes the Act of Conformity. The Presbyterians, having been marched out of Parliament by Cromwell, are now removed from their pulpits by Charles II.

[25:26] So I hope you understand why I have a great disdain for the Stuart monarchy and for Cromwell as well. He may have been a Puritan, but his mistakes in terms of independency and his own pride and self-centeredness in terms of rule just created another tyranny in England when the Puritan Revolution was lost.

[25:46] But what’s the difference between the Puritan Revolution, for all of the problems we talked about, and the French Revolution that comes about at the end of the 1700s. The Puritans were appealing to a law that permitted them to judge the king. In France, a higher law is totally thrown out so that eventually what you have is just anarchy, every man for himself.

[26:14] Well, the principles of Puritan political theory, though they do not eventually benefit long-term England, do come to expression in New England. And the Puritans, in what will become the United States of America, have a foundation for constitutionalism, viewing the law of God as above the civil government and so forth. Schaeffer reminds us that the Reformation insisted on the responsibility of all people, even monarchs, through the law of God. They believed in a government of law rather than by arbitrary decisions of men, and that therefore the law of God controls the sovereign in the political order.

[27:00] He looks at Rutherford’s Lex Rex, The Law is King, which was very influential on the writing of the U.S. Constitution via the Presbyterian churchman John Witherspoon. And Schaeffer tells us, and he’s exactly right, John Locke, who by the way lived through the Puritan Revolution, John Locke’s idea with respect to civil government was but a secularization of the Presbyterian tradition. that he would have been familiar with.

[27:32] There are problems in Locke’s philosophy. One, he holds to this empirical view that we know everything by our senses, but on the other hand, he holds to natural rights. Well, of course, through our senses, we aren’t able, looking at nature, to find anything about rights or wrongs or anything at all. Locke cannot make sense of his political philosophy in terms of the empiricism that he advances.

[27:56] Well, where does Locke get it then? Well, he got it from the Presbyterian. the bible does provide a foundation for the doctrine of inalienable rights you know these rights are not found in nature but rather nature’s god it does provide a foundation for government by consent a separation of powers and the right well Schaeffer puts it the right of revolution But what he means by this is the right of covenantal, you know, lawsuit against the king, that you can rebel against him because he has actually been the one who has rebelled against the law and has tyrannized the people.

[28:38] Schaeffer also reminds you in the chapter, and because you’re reading it, I’m just going to summarize, that the idea of democracy as the majority vote can create its own despotism. That if you do not put the reformational political changes into the context of the Christian world and life view, and you grant people the right to vote and so forth, but without the Christian worldview, that can become its own despotism where the majority can beat up on the minority without any restriction, without any restraint, because there’s no law. Law is just what the majority says. So you can have the despotism of the leviathan, the one man who imposes his law, or the despotism of the majority against the minority.

[29:26] And the only way to avoid those extremes, tyranny or, you know, gangsterism basically, and then anarchy, the way to avoid these things is to have a law over all of your political, over your society that creates your political institutions and guides them and restricts them.

[29:46] All right, so today we have studied the Reformation of Christianity, which is the parallel, the formal parallel, to the Renaissance of Humanism. If I can ask you to get in your helicopters again and get high above all these details, remember how I summarized the history of philosophy in the ancient world and medieval? we said in the ancient world we see the expression of pagan philosophy right and then in the midst of that darkness the light comes the way the truth and the life Jesus and the Christian church promotes a view of the world and of man and so forth different than what the pagans have and there was a real sense of antithesis between the church and the world paganism humanism was being answered by the truth of Christianity And for that, because of that antithesis, we see the conflict at Mars Hill philosophically.

[30:42] We see the conflict politically with the beast of Rome persecuting Christians and so forth. So we have paganism. Remember, I’m just giving you overall. We have paganism, antithesis, and then what does the Middle Ages represent? An attempt to somehow bring a little bit of paganism and a little bit of Christianity together in a fruitful union. So we have synthesis. Paganism, antithesis at the time of the early church, synthesis through the Middle Ages.

[31:11] Where does the synthesis, pardon me, end up? And a dichotomistic view where you have faith in one domain, theology in one domain, and then you have philosophy and reason and science and so forth in another. And the Renaissance picks up the seed of that dichotomy and runs with it. And what we see is the revival of that paganism. Isn’t that interesting? Now we’re going to go back and start again, have those wonderful classics of Greek pagan philosophy. I’m overdrawing it, but I just want you to see what’s going on.

[31:46] And at the same time, the Reformation wants to revive what? The original Christianity that’s back there. So now we have a new period of antithesis, don’t we? And this is what we are living at the end of, I believe.

[32:00] an age of antithetical conflict between the renaissance stream of thought and the reformational stream of thought and there are very few reformational thinkers around anymore but i being a post-millennialist believe that we will prevail whether in our generation our grandchildren but the fact of the matter is to understand western history after the renaissance i think you need to see this conflict between the renaissance mentality the reformational mentality and so at this point in the lecture which we’ll actually take up tomorrow morning now i want to look at two kinds of enlightenment we don’t have time in a course that’s modular and as we have to get through as quickly as we do to do this with every thinker but i want to give some detailed attention to calvin and to Hobbes as two ways of looking at Enlightenment. Divine Enlightenment in Calvin, and then the Enlightenment spirit of the materialism of Hobbes. up.


0:00 GLB Reading From Francis Schaeffer Cont. From Part 1 – Non-Christians Cannot Account For Science…& Must Borrow From The Christian’s Philosophical Worldview To Do It Successfully; Yet, They’ll Not Admit This, For They Suppress The Truth In Unrighteousness (Rom CH1)
1:02 Francis Bacon & His Quote From NOVUM ORGANUM 1620…Science Based On The Christian WV
1:45 Sir Isaac Newton & Other Christian WV Scientists…Blaise Pascal, Rene Descartes, Royal Society For The Improving Of Natural Knowledge
3:01 REFORMATION In The Sociopolitical Realm…In The Breakdown Of The Roman Catholic Church & Political Stranglehold Of Rome, Protestantism Brought About Freedom The Likes Of Which We See Today In The Western World
3:49 A Return To Biblical Christianity Formed A Unique Ethical Consensus & Framework (Though Not Perfect) That Prevented Tyranny On One Hand & Anarchy On The Other
5:35 The Puritans’ Understanding That The State & Church Must Submit To GOD’s Authority…THE WORD OF GOD MUST BE THE FOUNDATION FOR FREEDOM…The Results Of THE REFORMATION Is Perhaps Most Dramatically Seen In The Kind Of Political Reform Efforts That Rise Out Of It
7:15 …Not Claiming That Everything That’s Connected With Reformed Christianity, In Terms Of Sociopolitical Reform Was Pure & Correct…IT’S THE BIBLE THAT GIVES A BASE FOR LAW
8:58 Painting By Paul Roberts, JUSTICE LIFTS THE NATIONS
9:18 Alexandre Vinet Quote: “Christianity Is The Immortal Seed Of Freedom Of The World.”
9:51 Constitutionalism vs. Absolutism…What Happens If You Take Your Political View & Separate It From Scripture Is That You Finally Have Order In The State Only By Having Absolutism…The REFORMERS Exclaimed That All Princes Are Subject To GOD’s LAW & They Must Rule In A Constitutional Fashion
11:15 THE KING IS NOT ABOVE THE LAW!
12:00 FREEDOM UNDER THE LAW OF GOD…You Can’t Found Freedom In Freedom Itself
13:08 THE CONSTITUTION OF APPEAL & THE PURITAN REVOLUTION:
13:58 King Henry The Eighth vs. The Authority Of Rome (Power vs. Power With No Higher Appeal)
15:18 1600s King Charles (Sympathizes With Rome & Episcopalian Government) Appoints William Laud As Archbishop…People In England Oppressed By The Star Chamber & The High Commission Of The Church…Puritans Are Hated By Laud…Turd Quote Of Hatred
15:55 Persecuted Puritans Flee & Resulted In The Beginning Of America
16:32 The Tyranny Of King Charles…Scotland Opposes Him…Jenny Geddes Throws Stool
17:36 SCOTLAND GOES TO WAR…However, Ironically, They End Up Allies With King Charles In A Few Years…Here’s How:…The Short & Long Parliament…Civil War…Charles Flees
19:25 In The Absence Of A King, A Commission For Reform Of The Church Was Put Forth By The Puritan Parliament, Which Resulted In The Westminster Assembly & Eventually The Westminster Confession
19:56 The Puritans Are Not Doing Well In The War…Enter, Oliver Cromwell & Solemn League & Covenant With Scotland (Required Presbyterianism Be The United Kingdom’s Government Of The Church)
21:01 Charles Seizes Opportunity Afforded By The Trouble Between Presbyterians & Independents Within Puritan Party…Goes To The Scots & Forms An Alliance…Then Goes To War Against Cromwell & Is Slaughtered
21:41 Cromwell Doesn’t Have A Great Deal Of Sympathy For The Presbyterians Who Would Enter Some Kind Of League With Their Former King. Cromwell Therefore Established A Protectorate In England, With Himself As The Sole Protector For Life & Succession Is Hereditary
22:05 THE REPLACEMENT OF ONE ULTIMATE TYRANNY WITH ANOTHER ULTIMATE TYRANNY!
22:51 WHAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN DONE WITH CHARLES?
24:04 Who’s Waiting In The Wings To Takeover England?…Charles II The Prince Of Wales…Thomas “Leviathan” Hobbes (Political Philosophy Is That Religious Dissent Should Be Violently Put Down)…1662, Charles II Passes THE ACT OF UNIFORMITY
25:46 WHAT WAS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE PURITAN REVOLUTION & THE FRENCH REVOLUTION?…The Puritans Were Appealing To A Higher Law That Permitted Them To Judge The King; &, In France A Higher Law Was Totally Discarded
26:15 The Principles Of Puritan Political Theory Come To Expression In New England
26:38 GLB Highlights Some Of Francis Schaeffer’s Remarks On THE REFOMATION…Scottish Presbyterian Minister Samuel Rutherford’s Book, LEX REX (The Law Is King)…Influential Of The Writing Of The US CONSTITUTION Via The Scottish-American Presbyterian Minister John Witherspoon
27:14 John Locke’s Idea With Respect To Civil Government Was But A Secularization Of The Presbyterian Tradition…Problems With Locke’s Philosophy
28:38 DEMOCRACY & DESPOTISM…GLB Reiterates How A Return To Biblical Christianity Will Form A Unique Ethical Consensus & Framework (Though Not Perfect) That Prevents Tyranny On One Hand & Anarchy On The Other
29:45 SUMMARY