About This Lecture
In this course at Christ College, Dr. Greg L. Bahnsen examines the intellectual and cultural developments that shaped Western thought from the Renaissance and Reformation through the Enlightenment and Kant, concentrating on the period from approximately 1400 to 1800. He distinguishes the Reformation from the Renaissance, presenting the Reformation as a revival of New Testament faith in opposition to humanism and its assumptions about reason, tradition, man, nature, and freedom.
Bahnsen explores the defining convictions of the Reformation: the final authority of Scripture, salvation through the work of Christ alone, and the priesthood of all believers. He contrasts the biblical doctrine of justification through the imputed righteousness of Christ with the Roman Catholic emphasis on merit and works, while examining the tensions between humanism and the Reformation through figures such as Erasmus and Luther.
The lecture then considers the Reformation’s broader effects on Western civilization, including its influence on science, art, individual dignity, and social reform. Bahnsen addresses the biblical understanding of man’s greatness and wickedness, showing how the Christian worldview accounts for both. Drawing on the work of Francis Schaeffer, he concludes by examining the relationship between science and the Christian worldview. Throughout, Bahnsen offers presuppositional insights and internal critiques of unbiblical philosophies, demonstrating how intellectual and social challenges in our own day have roots in these earlier developments.
Table of Contents
- Renaissance and Reformation: Overlap and Distinction[00:00]
- Reformation as Revival of New Testament Faith Against Humanism[01:03]
- Contrasts: Reason, Tradition, Man, Nature, Freedom[03:03]
- Reformation Distinctives: Scripture, Christ’s Work, Priesthood[07:19]
- Sola Scriptura: The Bible as Final Authority[09:29]
- Salvation Only Through the Work of Christ[12:56]
- Two Kinds of Enlightenment[15:06]
- Priesthood of All Believers[18:53]
- Effects of the Reformation: Removing Humanistic Distortions[21:03]
- Roman Catholic Doctrine of Merit and Works[22:32]
- Justification: Christ’s Righteousness Imputed[32:51]
- Humanism’s Infiltration of the Church: Erasmus and Luther[34:42]
- Results for Man and Nature: Science, Art, Individual Dignity[37:08]
- Social Consequences: Equality and Reform of Society[41:12]
- Man’s Greatness and Wickedness Explained[42:47]
- The Reformation and Art: Iconoclasm, Cranach, Bach[47:15]
- Science and the Christian Worldview (Schaeffer, Chapter 7)[50:01]
Scripture References
| Timestamp | Reference | What’s there |
|---|---|---|
| [13:42] | Romans 1 | Bahnsen cites Paul in Romans 1 and quotes the statement “professing themselves to be wise, they became fools.” He uses it to explain why people surrounded by evidence of God still end up foolish, and tells students to remember it in a secular university class. |
| [14:20] | Romans 1:18 | Allusion: Following the Romans 1 citation, Bahnsen says people suppress the truth in unrighteousness without being self-conscious of it, and that the Bible says they have an axe to grind. He does not give a verse; the reference to Romans 1:18 is inferred. |
| [15:32] | Proverbs 1 | Bahnsen refers to Proverbs 1, which he says he mentioned at the convocation service, where God appears as personified wisdom calling people to love and follow her. He argues that Christians are to love wisdom and can do so only if God enlightens them. |
| [39:02] | Genesis 1:26–27 | Allusion: Bahnsen says the Bible teaches that man has dignity because he is made in the image of God, and argues that people can therefore do artistically and scientifically good works, though not meritoriously. He does not give a reference; Genesis 1:26–27 is inferred. |
| [43:03] | Isaiah 2 | Bahnsen cites Isaiah 2 as telling us to look for the day when men beat their swords into plowshares. He uses it to say that dominion over nature should be used positively, to produce things, glorify God, and serve his people, and not destructively. He says this is not pacifism. |
| [47:15] | Matthew 5:6 | Allusion: Describing the reformers who destroyed idols, Bahnsen says they were “hungering and thirsting for righteousness” and did not want the idols in the way. He does not give a reference; Matthew 5:6 is inferred from the phrase. |
Explore This Lecture Further
These study aids are built from the lecture. Each one summarizes the lecture’s argument in other words, so nothing here is Dr. Bahnsen’s wording unless it appears in quotation marks. Timestamps link to the audio. Where Bahnsen is reporting Francis Schaeffer’s book, the notes say so.
The Renaissance and the Reformation Compared
A summary of the contrasts Bahnsen draws. He cautions that the two periods cannot be sharply separated and that the distinction in the outline is somewhat artificial [00:00]. He argues that there is nonetheless an ideological and moral difference: the Renaissance wanted humanism revived, while the reformers wanted humanism removed from the church [01:03].
| Topic | Renaissance | Reformation |
|---|---|---|
| Looking back [01:36] | Looks back to the pagan Greeks, wanting to get away from the traditions of the Roman Catholic Church. | Looks back to the founding of the church and the original documents of Christianity, to God’s revelation (sola scriptura) rather than Roman Catholic tradition. |
| Reference point [02:22] | Man as the center of things and as autonomous. | The infinite personal God who has revealed himself in nature and redemptively in the Bible. |
| Reason [03:03] | Reason is not much affected by the fall; man can trust it and begin with himself. Bahnsen traces this to the seed planted by Thomas Aquinas. | Reason is as fallen as the will and the emotions. It is not self-sufficient, is put to an unethical purpose, and needs redemption. |
| Tradition [04:17] | Tradition is criticized because it did not hold to the autonomy of human reason. | Church tradition is criticized for its distortions, and the reformers call people to submit to God’s revelation in the Bible alone. |
| Man [05:02] | Begins with man as great and central. Bahnsen says that in the end man has no objective meaning or value and the world is disjointed. | Begins with God, and so can explain the meaning and dignity of man as well as why man has the problems he has. |
| Nature and art [05:34] | Art gives nature its proper emphasis but leaves the problem of finding meaning for the details. | Art gives nature a proper place as the creation of the infinite personal God, so nature has meaning and significance. |
| Freedom [06:03] | Freedom from tyrannical domination, but, as Schaeffer indicates, it often degenerated into license and anarchy, especially in Southern Europe, because humanism had no absolutes. | Freedom in the political order while standing under the authority of the Bible, which does not lead to license or anarchy. |
Bahnsen says Schaeffer will communicate that the two movements had the same basic problems but opposite answers, and that they led to opposite results [06:03].
Three Reformation Distinctives
Bahnsen lists three distinctives the reformers held over against the traditions of the Roman Catholic Church [07:19] and then returns to each in more detail.
| Distinctive | What Bahnsen says it is | Why he says it matters |
|---|---|---|
| The Bible as sole and final authority | There are not two ultimate authorities, the Bible and church tradition interpreting it, but the Bible alone [07:19]. The Bible is God’s word in all it teaches, and the church that proclaims it must itself be governed by it [09:29]. | He says the Bible gives genuine, though not exhaustive, truth about God, people, and the natural world, and so supplies a worldview [10:01] [10:47]. Reformed philosophy does not start with the Greeks’ assumptions about man’s mind and the truth, because only the Bible corrects the distortions of sin [12:05]. |
| Salvation only through the work of Christ | Salvation comes through Christ’s work and not through the works of men; Christ’s work is the only final hope [08:09]. | Individuals need not be tyrannized by church authority and can come to God directly by faith in Christ’s finished work, to which no one can add. Bahnsen calls this a key to doing philosophy properly [16:13]. |
| The priesthood of all believers | Church work carries no special religious dignity over other callings. Cobblers, fishermen, and farmers are priests before God, and the man who grows wheat is as religious as the man who dispenses the bread of life [08:27]. | Bahnsen reports Schaeffer on the screen that separated the people from the altar [18:53]. He adds that the reformers removed it and put the pulpit in the altar’s place, opening everything to God’s people on the basis of God’s word [20:00]. |
Why Redemption Is Philosophically Significant
A summary of the steps in Bahnsen’s reasoning, in lecture order.
- The Bible gives genuine truth about the God who unifies life and gives it meaning and value, and about people and nature [10:01] [10:47].
- So sola scriptura is philosophically significant: Reformed philosophy begins with the Bible and not with Greek assumptions [11:46] [12:05].
- Why don’t people reach these truths on their own? Bahnsen says we come into the world unable to figure things out, with hearts that suppress the truth, and handing truth to a fool does no good [12:56].
- He cites Paul in Romans 1 on those who professed to be wise and became fools [13:42], and adds that we suppress the truth without being aware of it and think we are innocent [14:20].
- His conclusion is that philosophy cannot be done until the problem of sin is dealt with and the philosopher is enlightened [14:20].
- He introduces his point on “two kinds of enlightenment” by noting that philosophy is the love of wisdom and that loving wisdom requires enlightenment [15:06]. He refers to Proverbs 1, where wisdom is personified and calls people to follow her, and says Christians can love wisdom only if God enlightens them [15:32].
- People who begin in darkness, as fools in rebellion, cannot make light out of their own darkness. Enlightenment requires regeneration, with God taking the initiative [16:13].
- God must also deal with the guilt that put people in darkness. Bahnsen therefore calls the whole scheme of redemption philosophically significant, and describes salvation through Christ’s work as the way back to the light that makes sense of the world, man’s place, and the meaning of life [16:13].
How Bahnsen Traces the Roman Catholic Doctrine of Merit
Bahnsen’s own account of how the doctrine develops, step by step. These are his descriptions and evaluations; this page summarizes them and does not check them against Roman Catholic sources. He notes that an informed Roman Catholic would call it a slander to say the church taught salvation by works, and says the problem is what is added to the affirmation of grace [22:32].
| Timestamp | Stage | Bahnsen’s description |
|---|---|---|
| [21:46] | Authority and merit | The church first raised its authority to equal the Bible’s. At about the same time, human works were added to Christ’s work, so that people could merit Christ’s merit. |
| [23:16] | Baptism and penalties | As he presents the dogma, only Christ’s work atones for sins before baptism. Sins after baptism call for eternal and temporal penalties. Christ’s work satisfies eternal justice, but temporal guilt remains. |
| [24:00] | Temporal guilt | He illustrates with being rude to a neighbor: God is displeased, and the guilt must be confessed and counterbalanced to satisfy God’s justice. |
| [24:40] | Confession and penance | The person confesses to a priest and is assigned acts, such as Hail Marys, to satisfy God. |
| [25:17] | Purgatory | For those who have not dealt with temporal guilt, God in his mercy instituted purgatory, where it is purged away. Bahnsen stresses that it is not part of hell. He objects that this makes God want people to suffer before entering heaven [25:50]. |
| [26:26] | Works of supererogation | Some special people did more than God required. These are works above works. |
| [26:55] | Treasury of merit | When such people enter heaven they have excess merit, which is placed in a treasury of merit for people who lack enough good works. |
| [27:28] | Distribution | God needs a representative on earth to distribute this merit and chooses the successor of Peter. Bahnsen remarks in passing that Christ’s merit might have been thought perfectly sufficient. |
| [28:13] | Classroom illustration | He imagines a student who must write ten term papers to make up for a failure and is then offered a saint’s surplus papers [29:06]. He says he is joking. |
| [29:14] | Indulgences and favor | He finds it abhorrent that the merit of the saints came to be sold, with an indulgence sparing the buyer purgatory. He then raises the question of why God favors some and not others, which he says Roman Catholic theologians answered with condign merit. |
| [30:50] | Grace turning into works | He says that step by step the scheme turns grace into its opposite: grace is preached, but works turn out to be required. |
| [31:03] | Congruent and condign merit | Works never fully accomplish everything, yet their merit is congruent with Christ’s. Condign merit is given to those whose lifestyle shows they are worthy of salvation. |
| [31:39] | Infusion | The person with condign merit is justified not by Christ’s work imputed to his account but by the infusion of Christ’s righteousness. God can declare a person just only if he is truly changed within. The reformers rejected this. |
Justification: Imputation or Infusion
A summary of the contrast Bahnsen draws, with each position described as he presents it.
| Question | Infusion (Rome, as Bahnsen describes it) | Imputation (the reformers, as Bahnsen describes it) |
|---|---|---|
| What God gives [31:39] | The righteousness of Christ is infused into the sinner. | God gives the sinner the credit, merit, record, and legal status of Christ. |
| Basis for declaring a person just [31:39] | God can declare a person just only if he is truly changed within. | The declaration rests on Christ’s record and has nothing to do with the condition of the heart [32:51]. |
| Illustration [32:51] | Not illustrated in the lecture. | A judge’s file for me holds a record of guilt, not my wicked heart. The reformers said Christ’s righteousness has been placed in my file as a gift, and the judge looks at my legal status, not my inner soul. |
| Meaning of the verb justify [33:43] | The reading Bahnsen argues against: that justify means to make someone just. | Justify means to declare righteous. In the New Testament people justify God, which cannot mean making God righteous, and justification is set against condemnation. If justify meant make righteous, condemn would have to mean make guilty. |
Bahnsen concludes that justification must mean being imputed with Christ’s merit, not meriting it [33:43].
Humanism in the Church: Erasmus and Luther
Bahnsen describes a pattern of humanist infiltration. First the church’s authority is raised to the level of the Bible’s, and then the merit of sinners is raised until it is congruent with Christ’s. The reformers wanted none of a humanism in which man has authority, value, and ability in himself, and they opposed even the Christian humanism of Erasmus [34:42].
| Question | Erasmus | Luther |
|---|---|---|
| The will | Taught the free will of man [35:32]. | Wrote on the bondage of the will [35:51]. |
| Man’s condition | Taught that men are basically good, innocent if nothing else [35:32]. | Not described in this passage. |
| Salvation | Taught that men can merit Christ’s merit, as the Roman Catholic Church had taught [35:32]. | Salvation is by grace alone because the will is in bondage and only God’s initiative can break the fetters [35:51]. |
Bahnsen uses the contrast to argue that the Reformation is philosophically significant and not merely theological. He rejects the idea that reason operates on its own while faith concerns getting into heaven. For him faith is foundational to reasoning, and theology answers philosophical questions. He mentions Van Til in this connection [35:51].
The Reformation’s Effects on Man and Society
A summary of the historical and cultural claims Bahnsen makes in the lecture, in lecture order. They are his claims as stated; this page does not evaluate them historically.
| Timestamp | Area | What Bahnsen says |
|---|---|---|
| [37:08] | Unity and value | Because the Bible gives genuine truth about God, the world and life have universal, objective value and unity. |
| [37:31] | Science and art | He reverses the common claim that going to the Bible kills interest in science and art. The Bible is the precondition for understanding the world and man’s life, and the impetus to study the world and show God’s glory in art, so the Reformation influenced science and art positively. |
| [38:36] | The individual | Reformation teaching gave meaning to the particular person, since people are not absorbed into the work of the church. The Bible explains how individuals such as Michelangelo, Bach, and Beethoven do great work. |
| [39:02] | Dignity and vocation | People have dignity as God’s image, so they can do works that are artistically and scientifically good, though not meritoriously. Every vocation has dignity and all God’s children are priests, which gives an impetus to good work even for a cobbler. |
| [39:50] | Equality and church government | All are equal before God and in the church. He says this does not require Anabaptism or a church without officers. In the Calvinistic wing, leaders are chosen by the people but may govern only if qualified, with the previous hierarchy certifying their orthodoxy. It is neither an all-out democracy nor a top-heavy tyranny. |
| [40:55] | The one and the many | He calls this the proper balance between the one and the many: law and order from the hierarchy, and freedom for the many to choose the men to whom they will be subject in the Lord. |
| [41:12] | Reform of society | He argues that this has explosive consequences for society. People who have a say in choosing church leaders would no longer accept the divine right of kings. He sees strong parallels between the U.S. Constitution and Presbyterianism. |
| [41:54] | Christian influence | He says it is naive to think John Locke and others devised this without Christian influence, though the influence was not perfect, pure, or simple. He says the Reformation provided the seeds of social reform and the foundation and precondition for scientific advance. |
Man’s Greatness and Wickedness
A summary of Bahnsen’s argument that the Reformation can explain both, in lecture order.
- He says the Reformation can explain why people are great and can do good things without losing absolutes [41:54]. Earlier he said the Renaissance begins with man as great but ends with man having no objective value [05:02].
- He says the Reformation is twice as good as the Renaissance because it can also explain why people are wicked [42:47].
- On the atomic bomb: he says people who point out that humanity mastered the atom and then built the bomb raise a good ethical question about why people turn mastery of nature to destructive ends. He says this is not pacifism and cites Isaiah 2, where swords are beaten into plowshares, as the right use of dominion: producing things, glorifying God, and serving his people [43:03].
- He describes a sermon he preached in Orange County as a protest against the idea that people are basically good, built on stories from the 1992 newspaper [44:14].
- He asks humanists to explain serial murder, warlords who let people starve needlessly, and children killing children [44:46].
- His answer is that Reformed Christianity can account for both human greatness and human wickedness, which is why the grace of God must be preached. Life cannot be figured out until the redemptive problem is dealt with [44:46].
- He rejects the objection that this is church stuff rather than philosophy. He says he is doing philosophy, explaining why people cannot get things figured out or live in peace and where moral absolutes come from, and concludes that the Reformation is a philosophical reform and not only an ecclesiastical one [44:46].
The Reformation and Art
A summary of how Bahnsen answers the charge that the Reformation was anti-culture. Where he relies on Schaeffer, the table says so.
| Timestamp | Question | What Bahnsen says |
|---|---|---|
| [44:46] | What is art’s significance? | For those with the Reformed outlook, art has religious significance and not merely aesthetic significance. It need not always have an explicitly religious or redemptive theme, because portraying the world God has made is legitimate and is itself religiously significant. |
| [44:46] | What is the charge? | The reformers have a reputation for destroying artistic images, and he says many Western history textbooks conclude from this that the Reformation was anti-culture, like fundamentalism. |
| [47:15] | How does he answer it? | Following Schaeffer, he says the images destroyed were those at the center of religious idolatry, destroyed because they were idols and not because they were art. The statues of Mary are an example. He thinks there were certain disasters and that the reformers may have gone too far, but says they were not against art. |
| [48:04] | What positive influence does he note? | Schaeffer points to Cranach’s portrait of Luther, who was his friend. Bahnsen goes on to the Geneva Psalter, Luther as a musician, Buxtehude’s Abendmusik, and the hymns that came out of the Reformation. |
| [48:33] | What about culture and Bach? | Culture was not restricted to the elite, since people could sing to glorify God. He calls Bach perhaps the greatest musician in Western history and says he wrote explicitly to the glory of God. |
| [49:03] | What about Rembrandt? | Rembrandt is his favorite. He says Rembrandt’s convictions were explicitly Reformed, and he sees Christian testimony and psychological depth in the painting The Raising of the Cross. Rembrandt knew both sides of man, his grandeur and his evil. |
Science and the Christian Worldview (Schaeffer, Chapter 7)
Bahnsen summarizes Schaeffer’s chapter 7 because, he says, the class will not have read it [50:01]. This page summarizes that summary, so the claims about China, the Arabs, Oxford, and the Galileo incident are Schaeffer’s as Bahnsen reports them.
Bahnsen gives his thesis as a sentence to write in the notes: “The rise of modern science is tied to a worldview which only Christianity can make sense of.” He says this differs from claiming that all modern scientists were explicit Christians [50:25].
- No one would have been interested in, or able to pursue, advances in science without a philosophical preconception that permitted study, experimentation, and generalization [50:25].
- Schaeffer notes that the Scientific Revolution arose almost simultaneously with the Renaissance and Reformation and dates modern science from Copernicus. Bahnsen stresses that the philosophical, political, and scientific figures are intertwined [51:19].
- The Chinese had scientific insights but could not theorize about how the world works. The Arabs, like the medieval Europeans, treated science as an aspect of philosophy, the exposition of Aristotle, and so worked by authority and not by observation [51:56].
- The foundation of modern science was laid at Oxford when scholars attacked Aquinas by showing that his chief authority, Aristotle, made mistakes about natural phenomena. Bahnsen says these scholars opened the door to less restrictive thought [52:32].
- The Roman church attacked Copernicus and Galileo because Aristotelian elements had become part of church orthodoxy. Galileo defended the compatibility of Copernicus with the Bible. Bahnsen says the Galileo incident was a conflict between a church bound by Aristotle and a man who looked at God’s world, and not a conflict between the Bible and science [53:05].
- Francis Bacon fought the old order of scholasticism and stressed observation and the systematic collection of data. Schaeffer says the rise of modern science did not conflict with the Bible and at a crucial point rested on it, and cites Alfred North Whitehead and J. Robert Oppenheimer, neither a professing Christian, as saying modern science was born out of the Christian worldview [53:39].
- Non-Christians can do science, but they cannot explain why the world is open to study, experimentation, and generalization. Bahnsen, reporting Schaeffer, says they are “philosophically living on borrowed capital,” using a Christian philosophy of life while denying it [54:34].
Francis Schaeffer in This Lecture
A guide to where Bahnsen is reporting Schaeffer’s book and where he adds his own comments. The transcript does not always mark the boundary.
| Timestamp | Topic | What the lecture attributes to Schaeffer, and what Bahnsen adds |
|---|---|---|
| [06:03] | Freedom | Schaeffer indicates that Renaissance freedom often degenerated into license and anarchy, and Bahnsen says Schaeffer will communicate that the two movements had the same problems and opposite answers. |
| [18:53] | The screen and the altar | Schaeffer says people were separated from the altar by a screen. Bahnsen adds a personal memory of delivering flowers to a Roman Catholic church [19:24] and the symbolism of the pulpit replacing the altar [20:00]. |
| [34:42] | The Bible as supreme authority | Bahnsen cites Schaeffer on a statue that marks the character of Reformed Christianity, with the Bible as the supreme and only authority. The name of the statue is unclear in the transcript. |
| [44:46] | Consequences for man | Bahnsen says Schaeffer looks at the Reformation’s consequences for man and that the class will look at them in a little more detail. |
| [47:15] | Iconoclasm | Bahnsen says Schaeffer does exactly the right thing in explaining that the reformers destroyed idols, not art. Bahnsen adds his own view that there were certain disasters. |
| [48:04] | Cranach | Schaeffer points to Cranach’s portrait of Luther. The transcript does not say whether the Geneva Psalter, Luther’s music, and Buxtehude come from Schaeffer. |
| [50:01] | Science | Bahnsen summarizes Schaeffer’s chapter 7 through the end of the lecture; see the resource on science above. |
Full Transcript
[00:00] All right, having taken a look at the Renaissance for some time, let’s turn our attention to the Reformation. It’ll be known to you from your general knowledge of the history of culture, but also from things we’ve said already, that you cannot sharply separate the period of the Renaissance from the period of the Reformation any more than you could separate the period of the Renaissance from the Middle Ages. What we’re looking at over this 200, 250-year period is the intertwining of various cultural and ideological movements and ideas, and we are going in and separating out events and thoughts that are uniquely reformational over against those things that had a different flavor and direction and purpose that we have labeled the Renaissance. So having said that, and noting the artificiality of the distinction in your outline, nevertheless, I would like to look at the Reformation.
[01:03] If the Renaissance was the revival of classical man-centeredness, what was the Reformation? It was the revival of New Testament faith and a reaction against humanism. This is interesting. The Renaissance, you see, wanted humanism revived. the reformers saw humanism in the church and wanted it extirpated. And so there’s really an ideological and a moral difference between what we will call the Renaissance and the Reformation.
[01:36] They have some formal characteristics that seem to make them common. They both want to go back, right? They look back to the glory of the past. But you see, that isn’t sufficient. You haven’t really gotten to the heart of it when you only say the Renaissance and the Reformation want to look back because the Reformation wants to look back to the founding of the church, to the original documents of Christianity, wants to go to God’s revelation, sola scriptura, rather than listening to the traditions of the Roman Catholic Church. whereas the humanists of the Renaissance want to get away from the traditions of the Roman Catholic Church, that they might go back not to the New Testament, but to the pagan Greeks.
[02:22] So while the Renaissance and the Reformation overlap geographically and chronologically, it’s rather obvious that the reference point for the Renaissance and the Reformation were quite different. In the Renaissance, the reference point was the humanistic ideal of man as the center of things. and man as autonomous, whereas in the Reformation, the reference point centered on the infinite personal God who has revealed himself not only in nature, but redemptively in the Bible. So we have a different reference point. Is it man as autonomous, or God who reveals himself?
[03:03] There’s a different attitude toward reason between the Renaissance and the Reformation. In the Renaissance, which is really growing the seed that had been planted by Thomas Aquinas, man’s reason is not terribly affected by the fall. I’m not sure it would be entirely fair to say that it was unfallen in their view, but nevertheless, it’s not so fallen as the will of man and other things that man cannot begin with himself. Man can trust his reason. The Renaissance says, take it for granted. Your reason will lead you to the truth. Begin with yourself, the Renaissance says, and by your reasoning ability, you can devise answers to mankind’s greatest questions. But in the Reformation, man’s reason is just as fallen as is man’s will or as emotion. And so the Reformation does not begin with the reasoning ability of man as self-sufficient and autonomous. It begins with the idea that the reasoning ability of man is being put to an unethical purpose. And it itself is distorted by the fall and needs redemption.
[04:17] The third point of conflict, in terms of the criticism of tradition. In the Renaissance, there was a critical attitude toward the accepted traditions of the Middle Ages. But tradition was criticized because it didn’t hold to the autonomy of human reason. In the Reformation, there’s a critical attitude to the traditions of the church and the distortions there. And that leads the Reformers to say man needs not to trust his reason, but to submit to the revelation of God in the Bible alone. So even in their dual critique of tradition, Renaissance and Reformed thinkers are different in what they propose as the solution.
[05:02] There’s a different view of man. In the Renaissance, we see Renaissance thinkers begin with man is great, man is central. In the end, man has no meaning or value, objective value. His world is disjointed without any kind of unity. In the Reformation, we begin not with man, but with God, and in beginning with God, we can explain the meaning and dignity of man, as well as why man has the problems that he does.
[05:34] Let’s compare nature and art. In Renaissance perspective, art gives nature its proper emphasis, but then leads to the problem of how can you find meaning for these details. In the Reformation, art gives nature a proper place, but as the creation of the infinite personal God. And so there is meaning in the natural world, there is significance in the natural world, because it’s been created by God and for his glory.
[06:03] Or consider the question of freedom, political, social freedom. Both the Renaissance and the Reformation were interested in producing a culture that was free of tyrannical domination by King. Both introduced freedom. But as Schaeffer indicates, the Renaissance concept of freedom, especially in Southern Europe, often degenerated into license and anarchy. because humanism had no way to give meaning to the particulars and no way to derive absolutes by which the particulars, individual men, should live. There were no values. The Reformation could introduce freedom in the political order, but do so by standing under the authority of the Bible. And so the freedom that is introduced in a biblical approach to politics does not lead to license or anarchy or a failure to find absolute values. So what I’m getting at here, what Schaeffer is going to communicate to you, is that the Renaissance and the Reformation had the same basic problems, but in very crucial ways, they had opposite answers. And the Renaissance and the Reformation led to opposite results.
[07:19] And so we’ve been looking at A in your outline, the contrast between the Renaissance and Reformation. Let me speak more specifically now, B, about the revival of New Testament faith and the Reformation reaction against humanism. What is the teaching of the Reformation? There are forerunners, of course, of the Reformation in the late Middle Ages, men like Wycliffe and Huss and somewhat Savonarola. but the Reformers specifically propounded as a distinctive over against the traditions of the Roman Catholic Church, one, that the Bible is our sole, final authority. There are not two ultimate authorities, the Bible and the tradition of the Church interpreting it, but rather the Bible alone.
[08:09] Secondly, the Reformers taught that salvation comes only through the work of Christ and not through the works of men. Only the Bible is our final authority and only the work of Christ is our final hope of salvation, not any work that we may do.
[08:27] And thirdly, Reformation distinctives are summarized in what is now called the priesthood of all believers. The idea that there is no special dignity or religious significance to being a person that works in the church like a priest, but rather all of God’s people, be they cobblers or fishermen or farmers, are priests before God and must pursue their vocations through his glory and under his direction. so that the man who grows wheat is just as religious as the man who dispenses the bread of life in the church. They are both priests before God. One’s calling is in the area of the church. The other’s calling is in the area of God’s world, but they nevertheless are equally religious, not as though one is more important than the other.
[09:29] Let’s talk about these three distinctives in a little more detail. First of all, the Bible is our sole and final authority. According to the Reformation, the Bible is the word of God in all that it teaches, and the church must live under the authority of the Bible. The question of ultimate authority in our philosophy of life then is not divided between the Bible and the church, But this institution that is charged with proclaiming the Bible itself must be governed by the Bible.
[10:01] Those with a reformed approach to life believe that the Bible gives them truth. Not all the truth, but nevertheless genuine truth about what is unavailable to human senses. The truth about God. We can know true things about the God that we do not sense because he has revealed himself not only in our own being as men, but in the world in which we live. We have absolute truth about the ultimate unity of life, the ultimate meaning of life, the ultimate value. We have absolute truth about God.
[10:47] Moreover, the Bible gives us not only absolute truth about God that unifies life and provides meaning and value, the Bible gives us truth about people and about the natural world. We understand why we exist, what man’s place in the universe is, why we have the form we do, how we are supposed to live our lives, what the natural world is there for, and why it is studyable, pardon the terrible English there, we know why it is studyable, why it’s accessible to man’s reason, and we know that we’ve been called to exercise dominion in it. All of this is given to us in the Bible. By beginning with the Bible, we have a worldview then. We know the invisible God who provides the unity, purpose, and meaning of all things, and we know what this world is all about as his creation, and man’s place in it.
[11:46] And so when the Reformation says we begin with the Bible, and the Bible is our final authority, it is our only final authority, this doctrine of sola scriptura is philosophically significant. We’ll talk about John Calvin in a few moments. I’ll draw this out even more.
[12:05] Reformed philosophy does not begin where the Greeks do. with the unquestioned assumption that man’s mind is normal with the unquestioned assumption that whatever is real all exist on the same level and can be understood by the same principle with the unquestioned assumption that man in his natural state has a pure interest in the truth and is not distorting the truth as he goes along Reformation says no we begin with the Bible because only that corrects our distortions only that corrects our misperception of the truth that comes about because of sin. Only that provides a unity, a universal broad enough to explain what the meaning of life is and how everything relates to everything else. Okay, let’s look at that second Reformed distinction.
[12:56] Salvation is only through the work of Christ. Now if we’re right in seed form here, I’ve suggested that the Reformation conception of sola scriptura provides a worldview you that answers these philosophical problems that are around, naturally we have to ask the question, well, why don’t men just of themselves come to those truths? As I’ve said, the Bible tells us we come into this world unable to figure things out. We come into this world not only with dark hearts, but with hearts that suppress the truth and therefore are led into darkness and ignorance. We are fools, to put it very simply. So you hand the truth to a fool, and it does you no good. God has handed the truth to fools.
[13:42] The world all around us tells us about God. We know we’re supposed to start with God. We know that we live our lives to serve his purposes. He is the unity. He is the absolute value, on and on and on. We should know all that, but we’re fools. But as Paul tells us in Romans 1, professing themselves to be wise, they became fools. That’s right. Remember that if you ever have to take a class at a secular university. Not professing themselves to be wise, they went out and proved how smart they were. Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools.
[14:20] And so we need a way back to God. We’re not able to take the truth that is so abundant and available to us and make good use of it because we’re suppressing it in unrighteousness. And we’re not even self-conscious of our suppressing it. We think we’re all very innocent. We believe in God and we would have this Christian worldview if the evidence was there. The Bible says we’ve got an axe to grind. And we’re suppressing this truth even why we think we’re being innocent. And so, to put it very simply, you can’t do philosophy unless you deal with the problem of man. The man who’s doing the philosophy. You can’t do philosophy until the problem of sin has been dealt with. until you are enlightened.
[15:06] And this is the key to my, I hope you find it clever enough to remember, this is the key to my next point in the outline, two kinds of enlightenment. See, philosophers will tell you, you need to love wisdom. That’s what philosophy is, right? Phileo, Sophia, the love of wisdom. Phileo, Sophia, philosophy. And to love wisdom, one must be enlightened.
[15:32] but we believe that we think we’re supposed to love wisdom in fact if you heard me at the convocation service the other night you know that Proverbs 1 has God as personified wisdom calling out to men to love him, to follow him that’s a feminine personification there, she holds out her hand, she extends it she wants men to come and follow her we’re supposed to love wisdom as Christians And we believe the only way you can love wisdom is if you are enlightened. Since we come into this world as fools in darkness, we need the enlightening of God.
[16:13] Now, doesn’t it stand to reason, doesn’t it just make sense to you, that if we begin our lives in darkness, with an axe to grind, rebelling against God, spiritually dead unenlightened if we begin as fools can we correct our own problem can we just take this natural foolishness we have and and use this foolishness to to make us wise people can we take all this darkness we have and create light out of it no if you begin with the reformed conception of man is falling then you don’t believe that you can get philosophical biblical enlightenment apart from what? Regeneration. God must take the initiative. God must change our lives. And, moreover, it won’t do any good for God to enlighten us if the guilt that has put us into this darkness remains. God must take care of the problem of man’s guilt. And therefore, the whole scheme of theology, which you probably will have an entire course in, or you can spend a life studying, and you hear preached all that. The whole scheme of redemption that is proclaimed in Reformed churches is philosophically significant. It’s crucial. The second distinctive of the Reformation that I’ve given you, salvation comes only through the work of Christ. This is important philosophically. Individuals, according to Reformed teaching do not need to be tyrannized by the authority of the church, either in its declarations or in its sacraments, as though we cannot be right with God apart from being right with the Pope and his minions. Rather, individuals can come to God directly by faith through the finished work of Christ. And no one can add to that finished work. Our enlightenment, our regeneration, our salvation has nothing to do with our accomplishments. We cannot add to the work of Christ. He has done it all. Therefore, the work of Christ is accepted as a gift, and those who accept it have been changed by the grace of God. This emphasis in the Reformation, that salvation is only through the work of Christ, therefore, is a key to doing philosophy properly, because it’s the only way back to the light, the light that enlightens everything else and makes sense out of the world, man’s place, and the meaning of his life.
[18:53] Well, then, how should we live our lives? If we see the ultimate authority of God’s revelation and the necessity of God saving work with Christ, the Reformation, as I indicated, taught the priesthood of all believers. As Schaeffer says, previously, people were separated from the altar in the church by a screen, and only the priest went to the center of worship. Only the priest went beyond that screen to the altar. I remember that very vividly.
[19:24] I grew up in a Roman Catholic community, and when I was in high school, one of the part-time jobs that I had was delivering flowers. And the very first time I went to the Roman Catholic, whether we had more than one, one major one there in town, to deliver flowers, I had to call ahead to get somebody who was a Roman Catholic to take the flowers up to where they were going to be near the altar because, you have to understand, I don’t have the right as a Protestant to be there. Well, as it turns out, people don’t have the right to be there. Only the priest has the right to be there.
[20:00] Now, what did the reformers do? Well, they removed this screen that separated the people from the altar, and they put in the place of the altar where the sacraments are celebrated, what? The pulpit. And in so doing, what they said is, everything’s opened up to all of God’s people on the basis of God’s word. Isn’t that a beautiful symbolism? We all come to God, and the word is central. We’re not screened off from the altar. and all of us must now take the word and live our lives out of it we are all priests we hear the word of God we go into the world to live the word of God it’s not just these people who do the hocus pocus of transubstantiation in the Eucharist in the Roman Catholic Church we’re all priests alright Christianity is reform what you find in the reformation is the revival of the faith against humanism rather than, as in the Renaissance, the glorification of humanism.
[21:03] What are the effects of the Reformation? What is the work and the outcome of the Reformation? Well, as I’ve said, if the Reformation is seen as a reaction against the distortions of humanism, whether they’re secular or religious, then at the core of the Reformation is a removal of those humanistic distortions that had entered the church. The reason why the Reformation focused on the church is that the problems in general culture and man’s understanding of himself would be corrected if the church preached the right things. But since the church is not doing that, then the church needs to be reformed.
[21:46] How had the church become so bad? Well, the authority of the church was made equal with the Bible to begin with. You have the Bible, God’s revelation, that is the source of our enlightenment, that should give us our philosophy of life, but the church has raised itself up to be equal to the authority of the Bible. Now when the church becomes equal to the authority of the Bible, it shouldn’t surprise us that about the same time, the work of Christ has added to it the work of man. So where Christ alone saves us, the church begins to teach that men can add to the work of Christ. They actually can merit the merit of Christ.
[22:32] And I want to make sure you understand this. I know you’re going to have theology classes, but we need just a few moments. Often Protestants will say, well, the Roman Catholic Church caught salvation by works. Well, just about any astute Roman Catholic will say, that’s a slander. That is not true. We do not teach and did not teach salvation by works. What Protestants should mean by that is what they did teach amounted to salvation by works, but nevertheless, when we point to Bible verses that say salvation is by grace, Roman Catholics would say, oh yeah, we believe that. It’s what they add to that. What they add to that that in a sense takes away the affirmation in the first place.
[23:16] Let me sit back and explain. According to Roman Catholic dogma, the work of Christ, and only the work of Christ, can atone for our pre-baptismal sins. Prior to the washing of baptism, nothing can take care of our original sin or any of the particular sins we are guilty of, except the work of Christ. But now somebody who’s been washed by baptism, when they sin after that, then the justice of God calls for a penalty, right? And the penalties of God are both eternal and temporal. Now only the work of Christ will satisfy the eternal justice of God with respect to our sin.
[24:00] But you know we all need to be disciplined when we have sinned. Let’s say that I have been rude to my neighbor this morning. Well, the civil magistrate doesn’t have the right to come in and rebuke me for being rude to my neighbor. And I don’t live at home anymore. My parents don’t rebuke me for being rude to my neighbor, but God’s displeased with me being rude to my neighbor. And so there is a certain temporal guilt that I have for my sin. How am I going to deal with that temporal guilt? Quite obviously, the justice of God would require me to confess the guilt and to do something to counterbalance it, to satisfy the justice of God.
[24:40] And so what I do is I go to a priest, and in the privacy of the confessional chamber, I say, Forgive me, Father, for I have sinned, and then I detail for him what it is. And he says, All right, then we do the following Hail Marys, and et cetera, et cetera, and God will be satisfied. Well, you might say, I don’t know, I don’t really like this. I think I’ll just skip all this temple judgment stuff, and I’ll just go to heaven when I die. No, no, no, no, if you have not taken care of the temporal guilt, you can enjoy the eternal.
[25:17] And so, since there are people who will make the mistake having been baptized and not dealing with their temporal guilt, God in his mercy has instituted purgatory. Isn’t that wonderful that you’ve turned the mercy of God into something that horrible? Purgatory is, as the name tells you, the place where all this temporal guilt is purged away. You need to realize purgatory is not part of hell when it’s not on the road to hell. No one who goes to purgatory is going to hell. Purgatory is the best view of heaven.
[25:50] And God wants people to suffer before they get into heaven. Does any of this beginning just seem outrageous to you? God wants you to enjoy his grace and mercy by first suffering in purgatory. But you say it’s necessary because you didn’t go to confessional, you didn’t take care of the temporal guilt of your sin. Now, let’s say you go to confessional and it turns out that what you have to do, either you don’t do or it’s just too much, it takes too much time, or if you die, before you get it all done. Isn’t God good? He says, that’s all right, I’ll still let you come to heaven. First off, to suffer first, have to make up for all of it.
[26:26] Or, hey, how about this? This is a great idea. God says, you don’t have enough good works to counterbalance this guilt. But there are certain special individuals, they were really good. In fact, they not only did all that I called them to do, they did over and above what I called for them to do. They got an A-plus above grade level. They did what are called works of super-erogation. These are the works above works, the super works.
[26:55] Now, when they enter heaven, you see, they’ve got an excess of merit on their account. So what God does is he says, well, what a shame to close this bank account with all this excess merit. I’ll scrape off this merit into the treasury of merit so that people who don’t have enough good worth can make use of the merit of the saint. This is amazing. You see how the grace of God works in the Roman scheme. scheme. God says, I’ll use the merit of the saints on your behalf. Isn’t that wonderful?
[27:28] One might have thought, just as an aside, that the merit of Christ was perfectly sufficient, and I don’t need the merit of the saints, but you see how the scheme all develops. It’s pretty, you know, point by point. Transitions are obvious. So God has all this excess merit. How is he going to distribute this merit? Well, he’s a representative, right? If you had invented something and you wanted to get it out to people, you would hire somebody to get your invention out, your new medicine, whatever it is. Well, similarly, God needs a representative on earth for the distribution of the merit of the saints, and he chooses the successor of Peter to do that. Okay. Now, the successor of Peter has got to get this merit out to people.
[28:13] Let’s imagine that you are a student of Dr. Bahnsen’s and you didn’t get your assignments done so you got a failure and then you decided because you didn’t think it was good to have on your transcript that you really wanted to go back and make that right. So you come to Dr. Botts and you say forgive me father I have sinned. Yes my son what have you done? I did not do your homework. You did not do my homework. So well what you’re gonna have to do then to make up for that is you’re going to have to do 10 term papers instead of one. Then I will know that you are very serious about this. And then you say, oh, but my father, I don’t have time to do 10 term papers. I could not even get one done. What will I do? I will die in my failure.
[29:06] And then I say, no, no, no. I have had better students than you before. They wrote more term papers than they needed.
[29:14] They did works of supererogation, and you know, I could only give them an A. There was no way to give them more than an A, and so what I have here is I have excess term papers that are all A work. And for a price, they are yours. Now, does that not seem gracious on my part? I am only selling these term papers for your good. Now, you know that I’m doing in cheek. I find it absolutely abhorrent that the day comes when men say we will sell you the merit of the saints. You may have an indulgence in your sin and therefore not have to go through purgatory and may enter heaven directly. Not only that the question arises why does God show favor to some men and not to others? The Roman Catholic theologians had to account to them. How does God show to some but not others? And the answer that they developed was some men have a certain condign merit that makes them worthy of God’s attention. That is, they have a merit that is appropriate to God’s attention. And so I’ve already demonstrated in terms of the congruent merit of man’s works, how Roman Catholics can say they’ve preached the grace of God and yet it turns out that you can’t get into heaven without doing works.
[30:50] That’s pretty clever, isn’t it? When you can take something and turn it into its opposite. We preach the grace of God, but step by step, as I’ve explained it, the grace of God turns out that you’ve got to do works.
[31:03] Now these works, it turns out, are never quite appropriate. They don’t fully accomplish everything, but nevertheless the merit of these works is congruent with the merit of Christ. But it turns out there’s another doctrine of merit in the Roman Church that’s just as bad, and that is the condign merit of God that is given to those who have shown by their lifestyle that they are worthy of salvation. Don’t waste time on the losers. God says, I’ll go for the people who are most likely to be religious and to be saved. Yeah, I know that’s very ugly. That’s a bottom line, but that is what Roman theology teaches.
[31:39] And then one more step in this perversion of the grace of God. Now it turns out that the one who has condign merit and is going to be justified before God and then do works of congruent merit, satisfy the temporal justice of God, avoid purgatory, go directly to heaven without pass and go, and so forth. that this person is justified not by the work of Christ imputed to your account, but you are justified by the infusion of the righteousness of Christ in you. That is to say, when God looks at a man and decides whether he is just or unjust, God can only declare you just if you truly are internally changed. And so justification must be God’s infusion of the righteousness of Christ into the sinner. The reformers, all pride, know. When God justifies the sinner, he does not infuse the sinner. He rather gives the credit, the merit, if you will, the record, the legal status of Christ to the sinner.
[32:51] Well, it’s as though, see a judge has all these files for every individual who lives, if I can give you an earthly analogy. And when the judge opens my file, what he would find there is a record of guilt. The judge does not find in the file my wicked heart, he just finds my track record that comes of course from my wicked heart. In the case of justification, the reformer said, when God opens the record for me, the merit of Christ, the righteousness of Christ has been placed in my file so that I have the gift of his righteousness. That has nothing to do with the condition of my heart. When the judge looks at my legal status, my file, he doesn’t see my inner soul, does he?
[33:43] And so in justification, God is declaring us righteousness. He is declaring us just for the sake of Christ’s righteousness. And the reformers all easily demonstrated that the word, the verb, justify, does not mean to make someone just. In the New Testament, we find that people justify God. That can hardly mean that people make God righteous. In the New Testament, we read that justification stands over against God’s condemnation. Well, given that parallel, if justify means to make righteous, then to condemn must mean to make guilty, to make unrighteous. And no one wants to say that of God. So, in the Reformed conception, justification must mean not meriting the merit of Christ, but being imputed with the merit of Christ. That’s what I was getting at.
[34:42] The infiltration pattern of humanism is first the authority of the church is raised to the same level as the authority of the Bible. And then we get the merit of sinners being raised up so that it’s congruent with the merit of Christ. But the Reformers wanted none of that kind of humanism, where man has authority and value and ability in himself. And so you have Pharaoh, for instance, opposing humanism. As Schaeffer says, the statue of Pharaoh marks the characteristic of Reformed Christianity. The Bible held the law over the head as the supreme and only authority. The Reformers even opposed the Christian humanism of someone like Erasmus.
[35:32] What did Erasmus teach that Luther found upon? He taught the free will of man. He taught that men are basically good, they are innocent if nothing else, and that men as the Roman Catholic Church had taught can merit the merit of Christ.
[35:51] against that. Please make my day. What was the title of Luther’s treatise? He taught what? The bondage of the will. The reason why it’s by grace alone is because the will of man is in bondage and only God’s initiative can break the fetters. So Reformed Christianity, I realize this may seem like we’ve descended into a class in theology, but one of the things I’m trying to illustrate for you is that at least this philosopher doesn’t buy this distinction. Theology is up there dealing with grace, but in philosophy we get down to object of reality in the world. I don’t buy that. I don’t buy the idea that reason operates on its own out there, but there’s also the faith we have to get into heaven. I believe that faith is foundational to our reasoning, that theology provides the answer to our philosophical questions. Or as Dr. Van Til, what if theology and philosophy address the same questions, but they do it in a different vocabulary? They do it with a different body. But it’s the same questions and the same answers. So the work of the Reformation is philosophically significant.
[37:08] What are the results of the Reformation with respect to man and nature? Results of the Reformation with respect to man and nature. Well, as I’ve said, the Bible gives us genuine truth about God so that we have a universal and objective value and a unity to the world that he made and the life that we live in it.
[37:31] because we see a unity to life in God’s creation and providence we therefore believe science and art can operate on a biblical foundation now I’m really reversing the kind of argument that you will ordinarily hear most people will tell you if you go to the Bible then you won’t be interested in art and you won’t be interested in science because you’ll just be all tied up here in your little religious revelation what does the Bible teach you? When you understand what the Bible teaches about God, about the world, man’s place in the world, the meaning of life, the calling of man, and so forth, the Bible, you see, is not only the philosophical precondition of understanding the world and man’s life, it is the impetus to getting out and understanding the world, and living our lives to God’s glory, and showing the glory of God in our artistic works, and so forth. So the Reformation had a positive, not a negative, a positive influence on science and art.
[38:36] With respect to man, Reformation teaching gave meaning to the individual, to the particular man. Because in the first place, men are not absorbed just in the work of the church. The Bible can explain why individual men do great things. How can a Michelangelo do this wonderful work? How can a Bach or a Beethoven write a symphony the way they do?
[39:02] Well, the Bible says man has dignity because he’s made in the image of God. If you think God did a good work and we’re his image, then we can do good works too, not good works meritoriously. I mean, we can do works which are artistically and scientifically good. And after all, since all vocations now have dignity, all of God’s children are priests before him. and they hear the preaching of the word and go out into the world to apply it, then there’s an impetus to do good work even if you’re just a cobbler. Those who write symphonies, those who discover medical advances, those who are farming, those who are making shoes, they all wish to glorify God, to live subject to what his word says, and to do their work to bring glory to his name.
[39:50] Moreover, the results of the Reformation with respect to man show that all men are equal before God and in the church you don’t exalt one over the other. Now does this mean we should all be Anabaptists? We should all hold a view of church government that doesn’t say that there are officers in the church? Absolutely not. And notice this distinctive. In the Reformation at least as it comes to expression through the Calvinistic wing, the Reformation those who govern the church govern because they are chosen by the people but they may not govern the church unless they are qualified and the hierarchy, the previous hierarchy of the church certifies their orthodoxy so you do not have in reformed Christianity with respect to the government of the church either an all-off democracy where the people have their way no matter what nor do you have a top-heavy tyranny where it’s only those who are already in the club choose those who will be in the club.
[40:55] You have, to put it more philosophically, you have the proper balance between the one and the many. The law and order side of things, the previous hierarchy, as well as the many having the freedom to say which men they will be subject to in the Lord.
[41:12] And so Reformation Christianity in its view of man and the government of the church has explosive consequences for the reformation of society as well. No longer would the divine right of kings have a stay of life when reformed people know that even in the church they have a say in the choosing of their leaders. And this is not just Presbyterian prejudice that’s coming out. I hope that you have noticed if you read the U.S. Constitution and the form of government we have, that there are strong parallels to Presbyterianism there, see? Where did people get that idea?
[41:54] But if you buy the story that John Locke and his friends, you know, just ignoring any Christian influence, came up with this on their own, you are naive. In fact, I’d like to tell you about Santa Claus and a bridge I have to sell and so forth. That came from Christian influence. Not perfect, not pure, not simple necessarily, but when all is said and done, the bottom line is the Reformation provided the seeds for social reform. The Reformation provided the foundation and precondition for scientific advance. The Reformation, you see, could show why we can put an emphasis upon nature and details and study the relationships of people to one another without losing absolutes. Reformation could explain why men are great and can do good things.
[42:47] But you know, the Reformation is twice as good as the Renaissance. Not only could it explain the goodness of man, it could explain why men are wicked too. So here are men who have the ability to study the natural world and what they do.
[43:03] they master the natural world so that they can kill each other I’m not some kind of raving peacenik and so forth, I’m here to teach you but you know, when people point out that we’ve mastered the atom for instance, and then we made the atom bomb they make a good ethical point why should it be the case that when men come to master nature they turn it to destructive ends the Bible tells us It’s not peacemikism. The Bible tells us in Isaiah 2 we should look for the day when men will take their swords and beat them into plowshares. That we should use our ability to have dominion in this world, not to fight with each other destructively and wickedly, but use it positively to produce things and to glorify God and to serve his people. So again, I realize you hear this from people that may not be all that commendable in their philosophy of life, but they make a good point. How can men who are good and smart and able to have this kind of control of nature, why do we do so many bad things?
[44:14] This last year, where I preach fairly regularly in Orange County, my first sermon of the year was a protest against humanity. Basically what I did is that I am fed up of all of this namby-pamby humanistic garbage about how men are basically good. And then I just took the newspaper for 1992 and I said, look at this story, look at this story, look at this story. You can do this throughout history too, not just 1992.
[44:46] What I want to know is, if you think men are basically good, okay you humanists, you Renaissance children out there, please explain to me why people engage in serial murder, why in some countries of the world, warlords let people starve to death when they don’t need to, why you have children killing children, and on and on and on. You see, the interesting thing is, Reformed Christianity can not only account for the greatness of man and what he can do, but also account for why he is such a horrible, wicked person. I mean, that’s why the grace of God has to be preached. You can’t figure out life until you deal with the redemptive problem as well. That is not somehow, oh, that’s church stuff. That’s theology. Let’s get back to philosophy. I’m doing philosophy. I’m trying to explain to you why men can’t get things figured out. Why they can’t live together in peace. I’m trying to explain where moral absolutes come from and what do we do when it turns out we violated those moral absolutes okay so with respect to man don’t you see the reformation is not just an ecclesiastical reform it’s a philosophical reform and it has marvelous consequences schaefer looks at them and we’ll look at them in a little more detail ourselves let me move on to art the results or effects of the reformation in art for reformers those with the Reformed outlet, art has religious significance, not merely aesthetic significance. But that doesn’t mean that art is only usable in the church or in Sunday school material. We’re not saying that art must always have an explicitly quote-unquote religious, church-oriented or redemptive theme. Art, portraying the world God has made, is legitimate. But even that is religiously significant. Now, the reformers, it so happens, have a history, a reputation for destroying artistic images. And so, you know, how many textbooks on Western history will then say, see, the Reformation was like fundamentalism. It was anti-culture. Because reformers destroyed these images.
[47:15] Well, Schaeffer does exactly the right thing. You know what images they destroyed? The ones that were at the center of religious idolatry. They did not destroy them because they were art. They destroyed them because they were idols. Now, maybe you think they went too far. I think there were certain disasters. But I don’t make the mistake of thinking they were against art. They were, with all their heart and soul, hungering and thirsting for righteousness and therefore didn’t want these idols that had brought people down to be in the way anymore. So when they destroyed art, they were destroying the religious, anti-religious, actually, significance of those artistic pieces, the statues of Mary and so forth.
[48:04] Let’s note the positive influence of the Reformation on art and culture. Schaefer points to Cranach in his portrait of Luther, who was a friend of his. Consider the Geneva Psalter and what that meant for the Reformation of the Musen. That Luther was a musician. In fact, he wrote the preface to the Wittenberg of the Songen book. Think of Buxtehude’s Abendmusik, the hymns that come out of the Reformation.
[48:33] Culture not being restricted to the elite. People should be able to sing to glorify God, and to sing in church, or even more, the work of Bach. The testimony signatures of Bach bring tears to my eyes. Here is perhaps the greatest musician in the history of the Western world, and he wrote these pieces to the glory of God explicitly.
[48:58] Anvil, who put the Bible at the center of his great musical compositions.
[49:03] who took nature seriously, painted biblical themes, who was interested in the treatment that was being given to Luther because he believed Luther’s theology. Or Rembrandt, my favorite. I mean, that’s a subject of remarkable. I mean, everyone grants the grand group of Rembrandt, explicitly reformed in his convictions. You see his Christian testimony in the painting, The Raising of the Cross, you see the psychological depth. Rembrandt knew both sides of man, his grandeur as well as his evil. Consider the results and effects of the Reformation in the scientific world. When I gave you your reading assignment last evening, I thought three chapters would be more than enough. Do you recall that I told Schaefer wrote his book in a somewhat what we would consider unorganized way.
[50:01] Well, it turns out that he discusses this particular theme in Chapter 7, okay? And so you will not have read it. If you want to, turn in your book to Chapter 130. I’m just going to go through real quickly and summarize what he has for us here because he doesn’t restrict himself just to the time of the Renaissance and Reformation. He finally comes up into the 20th century as well.
[50:25] But the point that he’s trying to make here in chapter 7 is that the rise of modern science is tied to a worldview which only Christianity can make sense out of. I would advise you to write that sentence in your notes, because I think that’s the precise way to put it. The rise of modern science is tied to a worldview which only Christianity can make sense of. That is different from the claim that all the modern scientists were explicit Christians. They may not have, or they may have had, you know, certain problems in their theological expression. But the point is, no one would have been interested and therefore able to pursue the advances in science if they couldn’t make sense of this world, if there was no philosophical preconception that permitted study, experimentation, and generalization.
[51:19] Schaeffer tells us at the beginning of the chapter that almost simultaneously we have not only the Renaissance and the Reformation, but what is called the Scientific Revolution. He suggests we date the rise of modern science from Copernicus, of course you know from my lectures that we get a little more detail on that. It’s not up here on the board today because I’ve limited space, but please remember that, those names and those two columns. have all of these people intertwined, you know, the philosophical and the political and the scientific, and it’s not just like in one little segment of time.
[51:56] Anyway, he chooses Copernicus as his jumping off spot. He points out the Chinese developed very few scientific theories. They had scientific insights, but they could not theorize about the world in the way that it works. He looks at the Arabs at the bottom of the page, and he says, like the medieval Europeans, Their science was an aspect of philosophy, meaning the exposition of Aristotle. So they did science not by observation, but by authority and interpretation of their authority, Aristotle.
[52:32] So then it says, the foundation for modern science can be said to have been laid at Oxford when scholars there attacked Thomas Aquinas’ teaching by proving that his chief authority, Aristotle, made certain mistakes about natural phenomena. Then he mentions Roger Bacon. We all know the name of Bacon. We spent some time on him. He mentions Protesta. We haven’t spent much time there. I would probably not give that much emphasis to him, but nevertheless, what he says is these scholars opened the door to less restrictive thought.
[53:05] And then he talks about the Roman church attacking Copernicus and especially Galileo. And he says this is because Aristotelian elements had become part of church orthodoxy. He reminds us that Galileo defended the compatibility of the view of Copernicus with that of the Bible. So those who make the Galileo incident a conflict between the Bible and science have missed the point. It was a conflict between the church bound by Aristotle and Galileo who went to look at God’s world and said, hey, you’re wrong.
[53:39] On page 132, he discusses Francis Schaeffer, Francis Bacon, let’s see if we get this right. Francis Schaeffer discusses Francis Bacon in his battle against the old order of scholasticism, his stress on observation, a systematic collection of the data, information, the emphasis of Galileo, and the New Telescope, and then in the middle of the page, let me read, the rise of modern science did not conflict with what the Bible teaches. Indeed, at a crucial point, the scientific revolution rested upon what the Bible teaches. And then he cites two men, neither of whom are professing Christians, Alfred North Whitehead and J. Robert Oppenheimer, who have stressed that modern science was born out of the Christian worldview.
[54:34] On the next page, Schaeffer explains, this does not mean that it’s only Christians who can do science. But when non-Christians do science and are successful at it, they cannot give an account of their success. They cannot explain why the world is amenable to the study, experimentation, and generalizations that they have. Therefore, when non-Christians do science successfully, they are philosophically living on borrowed capital. That is, they’re really using our philosophy of life, all the while denying that. Thank you.
0:00 Separating Out Events & Thoughts That Are Uniquely REFORMATIONIONAL From Various Cultural & Ideological Movements & Ideas That Have Been Labeled THE RENAISSANCE
1:00 (REF)ORMATION: Revival Of NT Faith & A Reaction Against Humanism | (REN)AISSANCE: Revival Of Classical Man-Centeredness
1:16 A) CONTRAST BETWEEN REN & REF
3:03 Different Attitude Toward Reason Between REN & REF – (REN) Man’s Reason Is Not Affected By THE FALL & Is Self-Sufficient… | (REF) Man’s Reasoning Is Distorted By THE FALL & Isn’t Self-Sufficient & Needs Redemption
4:17 Critical Attitude To Tradition – (REN) Criticized Because It Didn’t Hold To The Autonomy Of Human Reason | (REF) Man Needs Not To Trust His Reason, But To Submit To The Revelation Of GOD & THE BIBLE ALONE
5:02 View Of Man – (REN) Man Is Central & Great, Yet Has No Objective Value & His World Is Disjointed & Without Any Unity | (REF) Begins With GOD, Which Can Explain The Meaning & Dignity Of Man & His Condition
5:34 Nature & Art – (REN) Art Gives Nature An Emphasis Yet Leads To The Problem Of Meaning | (REF) Nature Is GOD’s Creation & Has Meaning & Significance Because It Has Been Created For HIS GLORY
6:03 Question Of Political & Social Freedom – (REN) Often Degenerated Into License & Anarchy Because Humanism Had No Way To Derive Morality | (REF) By The Authority Of THE BIBLE, Could Account For Morality, Social & Political Freedom.
7:02 Summary (Contrast)
7:25 B) RIVAL OF NEW TESTAMENT FAITH & THE REF REACTION AGAINST HUMANISM
7:34 1) Bible Is Our Sole Final Authority
8:09 2) Salvation Comes Only Through THE WORK OF CHRIST, Not The Works Of Man
8:27 3) Priesthood Of All Believers
9:29 THREE DISTINCTIVES IN MORE DETAIL
9:32 1) Moreover, The Bible Gives Us Not Only Absolute Truth About GOD That Unifies Life & Provides Meaning & Value, The Bible Gives Us Truth About People & The Natural World
11:59 Reformed Philosophy Contrasts Greek Philosophy
12:53 2) We Need A Way Back To GOD, But We’re Fools Who Suppress The Truth In Unrighteousness
14:49 Therefore, You Can’t Do Philosophy Unless You Deal With Man & His SIN—You Must Be Enlightened With CHRIST’S WISDOM (Col2:3)
15:14 Two Kinds Of Wisdom: Fallen Man’s & Regenerated Man’s
17:33 Right With GOD By Faith Through The Finished WORK OF CHRIST Apart From The Pope & His Minions…Philosophical Significance
18:53 3) Since CHRIST Has Given The Perfect Sacrifice, Reformers Replaced The Altar With The Pulpit Because All Of CHRIST’s Followers Have Access To GOD’s WORD, To Be Lived Out As Priests In The World (1Peter2)
21:03 WHAT ARE THE EFFECTS OF THE REF?
21:12 – Distortion Of Humanism Removed From The Church…
21:45 HOW HAD THE CHURCH BECOME SO BAD?
21:49 – Authority Of The Church Was Made Equal With The Bible…Men Adding Works To Salvation Soon Followed
22:33 – Roman Catholic Word Dance Regarding Salvation (Temporal Punishment/Guilt & Purgatory)
26:09 – Supererogation & The Treasury Of Merit
28:06 – Treasury Of Merit…Term Paper Analogy
30:05 – Condign Merit
30:35 – Congruent Merit “…We Preach The Grace Of GOD.” BUT CLEVERLY, STEP BY STEP REVEALS, YOU HAVE TO DO WORKS!
31:39 – Infused Righteousness
34:41 (…SO BAD?) RECAP
35:05 W. Farel Opposed Humanism | D. Erasmus, Taught The FreeWill Of Man | M. Luther’s, THE BONDAGE OF THE WILL…Expands
36:09 UNITY BETWEEN THEOLOGY & PHILOSOPHY, Van Til – “Theology & Philosophy Address The Same Questions But They Do It In A Different Vocabulary.”
37:08 WHAT ARE THE RESULTS OF THE REF WITH RESPECT TO MAN IN NATURE?
37:31 – Because We See A Unity To Life In GOD’s Creation & Providence We Believe It’s The Impetus For Understanding The World
38:35 – Reformation Teaching Gave Meaning To The Individual…Expands To All Vocations
39:50 – All Men Are Equal Before GOD…The Proper Balance (The One & The Many) Of Church & Civil Government…
41:39 – Presbyterianism’s Influence On American Form Of Government…Not Perfect, However, THE REF Provided The Seeds For Social Reform!
42:41 – Could Explain Why Men Are Wicked
45:54 Summary (…MAN IN NATURE?) REF Wasn’t Just A Ecclesiastical Reform; It Was A Philosophical Reform
46:13 WHAT ARE THE EFFECTS OF THE REF OF ART?
46:44 – Has Religious Significance: All Vocations/Actions Can Give Glory To GOD (1Cor10:31) | “Art” The Reformers Destroyed
48:04 – Positive Influences On Art & Culture: Bach, Handel, Rembrandt, etc.
49:42 WHAT ARE THE EFFECTS OF THE REF ON THE SCIENTIFIC WORLD?
50:28 – “Rise Of Modern Science Is Tied To A Worldview Which Only Christianity Can Make Sense Out Of” – Francis Schaeffer
51:23 – Scientific Revolution … Compares Scientific Practices During The Period With Other Nations
52:31 – Scholars Who Opened The Door To Less Restricted Thought
53:04 – Roman Catholics Attack
54:07 – Scientific Revolution Rested On What The Bible Teaches
54:34 – Non-Christians Cannot Account For Science…