*Note: Source Audio Contained Glitches
About This Lecture
In this Reformation Sunday sermon, Dr. Greg L. Bahnsen examines the biblical foundations and historical significance of the Protestant Reformation, beginning with Paul’s teaching in Romans 1:1–17 and Luther’s rediscovery of the declaration that “the righteous shall live by faith.” Bahnsen traces the Reformation’s development through Luther’s 95 Theses, the controversy over indulgences and purgatory, and the confrontation at the Diet of Worms. He explains why reform was necessary, addressing the doctrines of Sola Gratia and Sola Scriptura, the authority of Scripture over tradition and papal claims, and the priesthood of all believers. But Bahnsen does not leave the Reformation in the sixteenth century. He warns of its decline through historical and contemporary compromises, including the softening of the antithesis with Rome and the loss of Reformation convictions in modern culture, churches, and personal Christian life. The sermon concludes with a call for continued reformation, greater consistency and obedience to God, and prayer for revival.
Table of Contents
- Introduction: Reformation Sunday[00:00]
- Theme and Text: Romans 1:1–17[00:35]
- Luther and “The Righteous Shall Live by Faith”[02:47]
- Reform Throughout Covenant History[04:04]
- The Reformation Begins: Luther and the 95 Theses[06:58]
- Indulgences and Purgatory[09:29]
- Diet of Worms and the Rise of Protestantism[14:36]
- Why the Reformation Was Necessary[18:36]
- Sola Gratia: Merit and Justification[21:10]
- Sola Scriptura: Tradition and Papal Authority[26:39]
- The Priesthood of All Believers[29:24]
- The Reformation Dying: Anabaptists[33:39]
- Softening the Antithesis with Rome[34:25]
- The Reformation Dying in Our Culture[35:31]
- The Reformation Dying in Our Churches[36:27]
- The Reformation Dying in Our Personal Lives[39:08]
- Closing Prayer for Revival[40:26]
Scripture References
| Timestamp | Reference | What’s there |
|---|---|---|
| [00:59] | Romans 1:1–17 | After announcing Romans 1:1–17 as his text, Bahnsen reads the passage aloud. The reading continues through the next several paragraphs and is the sermon’s stated text. |
| [02:47] | Romans 1:17; Habakkuk 2:4 | Bahnsen finishes the reading with Paul’s statement that the righteous shall live by faith. He then says this was the verse through which Luther grasped the gospel, and names Habakkuk as the source of the quotation. He gives the book only; chapter and verse are identified from the wording. |
| [04:54] | 2 Kings 22–23; 2 Chronicles 34 | Allusion: Bahnsen recounts Josiah’s reform, in which a book of the law, which he takes to be Deuteronomy, was found while the temple was being cleaned and led to a war on idolatry. He does not name a passage. The narrative is identified from his description, and the parallel accounts are listed together. |
| [04:54] | Malachi | Bahnsen cites Malachi, the last prophet of the Old Testament, as calling God’s people to reformation, with God’s declaration that he would purify his people and the temple. He gives the book only. |
| [05:37] | 1 Corinthians | Allusion: Bahnsen points to Paul’s correction of the Corinthian church, which Paul still addressed as saints while calling for reformation. He does not name the letter; 1 Corinthians is an inferred identification. |
| [05:37] | Revelation 2–3 | Bahnsen cites Jesus’ letters, through John, to the seven churches of Asia Minor in Revelation 2 and 3, and points to their constant call to repentance, change, and obedience. |
| [22:16] | Hebrews 11:6 | Bahnsen cites Hebrews 11:6, that without faith it is impossible to please God, to argue against Rome’s congruous merit and to show that the unregenerate do no good works. |
| [22:16] | Romans 8:8 | Bahnsen cites Romans 8:8, that those in the flesh cannot please God, in the same argument that no favorable quality attends the work of unbelievers. |
| [23:13] | Romans 6:23 | Bahnsen reads Romans 6:23, that the wages of sin is death and the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus, in support of Calvin’s teaching that even the works of the regenerate have no deserving merit. |
| [23:13] | Ephesians 2:8–9 | Bahnsen reads that we are saved by grace through faith, not of ourselves and not of works, so that no one may boast. He names Ephesians 2 only; the verse numbers are identified from the wording he reads. He concludes that believers have nothing to boast in their works. |
| [27:19] | Galatians 1:8–9 | Bahnsen says Paul in Galatians 1 declared accursed any teaching of this kind, even if an angel taught it, and applies this to Rome’s teaching. He says this is why Rome appealed to church tradition and an infallible pope. The verse numbers are identified from his description. |
| [27:55] | Matthew 15 | Bahnsen says Christ in Matthew 15 condemned human tradition that supplants the word of God, and reads the saying that by their traditions people undo God’s word. He uses it to introduce sola scriptura. |
| [27:55] | Isaiah 29:13 | Bahnsen says Christ was quoting Isaiah in the saying about honoring God with the lips while the heart is far away. He names the book only; Isaiah 29:13 is an inferred identification. |
| [27:55] | 1 Corinthians 2 | Bahnsen says the Reformers distinguished the wisdom of men from the wisdom of God as Paul does in 1 Corinthians 2. He adds, as Paul said, that faith should stand in the power of God and not in the wisdom of men, without giving a separate citation. |
| [27:55] | Deuteronomy 4 | Bahnsen cites Moses’ declaration in Deuteronomy 4 as the reason the Reformers would not have anything added to God’s word. |
| [27:55] | Jeremiah 23 | Bahnsen cites Jeremiah 23 for the warning to be careful of prophets who speak a vision from their own heart and not from the word of the Lord, and says the Reformers heeded it. |
| [30:43] | 1 Peter 2; Exodus 19 | Bahnsen says 1 Peter 2, quoting Exodus 19, teaches that all of God’s people are priests who go before God’s throne through their one mediator, Jesus Christ. He draws from it that there is no sacred and secular distinction among callings. He gives chapters only. |
| [41:38] | Galatians 1:8–9 | Allusion: in the closing prayer, Bahnsen asks for righteous indignation against those, even angels from heaven, who would declare that anything could be added to Christ’s merit. He does not name the passage; it matches the Galatians 1 teaching he cited at 27:19. |
Explore This Lecture Further
These study resources summarize how Dr. Bahnsen’s argument is built. They are summaries of the lecture, not his words, and every point carries a green timestamp so you can check it against the audio.
The Reformation Timeline as Bahnsen Tells It
The dates and events below are the ones Bahnsen gives in the lecture, gathered in one sequence.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| October 31, 1517 | Luther announces a disputation on indulgences, stated in 95 theses. Bahnsen says this was ordinary academic practice, not an act of defiance. [06:58] [07:30] |
| 1518 | Luther holds a disputation at Heidelberg within his Augustinian order, and another with papal authorities at Augsburg. [12:04] |
| 1519 | Disputation with papal authorities at Leipzig. [12:04] |
| 1520 | Luther is excommunicated by the Pope. [12:04] |
| 1521 | At the Diet of Worms Luther is outlawed by Emperor Charles V after refusing to recant. [14:36] [15:00] |
| Over the next 25 years | Luther publishes book after book for ordinary readers and translates the Bible into German. [15:46] |
| 1529 | At the Diet of Spire, German princes protest Charles V’s attempt to curb the Lutheran movement, and those who protest become known as Protestants. [16:26] |
Key Terms in the Lecture
Each entry describes how Bahnsen uses the term in this lecture.
| Term | How Bahnsen uses it |
|---|---|
| Indulgence | The release of a sinner from the penance needed to stay out of purgatory, or from some period in it. Its sale to fund the Pope’s projects became, in Luther’s eyes, an outrageous scandal. [09:29] [12:04] |
| Purgatory | The place where, in Rome’s teaching, the temporal penalties for post-baptismal sins are suffered. Bahnsen says medieval Christians dreaded it, though it was not hell forever. [10:54] |
| Synergism | The label Bahnsen gives to Rome’s teaching that God and the sinner work together to bring about salvation. [23:13] |
| Alien righteousness and infused righteousness | Bahnsen sets the sinner’s trust in the alien righteousness of Christ alone against Rome’s definition of justification as God infusing righteousness into the sinner. The difference is whether justification rests on something in the sinner or entirely on the Savior. [24:01] |
| Antithesis | The sharp line Bahnsen says must be exalted and guarded between Reformation faith and Rome, out of love for Christ and the purity of his word. He calls the two “two different religions.” [20:16] [34:25] [34:59] |
| Cheap grace | Luther’s charge that indulgences let a man go on sinning while planning to buy his way out of suffering. Bahnsen later applies it to Protestants who think forgiveness is easy and no changed life is needed. [12:04] [39:48] |
| “Reformed and always reforming” | The motto Bahnsen draws from covenant history: God’s people have been changed by God, yet the call to greater reformation is always there. [04:04] [05:37] |
Merit and Justification: Rome and the Reformers
This table sets out, row by row, the contrast Bahnsen draws on the question of how a sinner is made right with God. The left column is Bahnsen’s description of Rome’s teaching, and the right column is his account of the Reformers’ answer.
| Question | Rome, as Bahnsen describes it | The Reformers, as Bahnsen presents them |
|---|---|---|
| Do the good works of unbelievers count for anything? | Congruous merit: a favorable quality in the works of unbelievers, before conversion, that moves God to give grace. [21:10] | Calvin was horrified at this. Bahnsen says the unregenerate do no good works and points to Hebrews 11:6 and Romans 8:8. [22:16] |
| Do the good works of believers deserve eternal life? | Condign merit: the value of works done after conversion would entitle the believer to eternal life, with Christ’s blood added to it. [22:16] | Calvin said there is no deserving merit even in the works of the regenerate. Bahnsen cites Romans 6:23 and Ephesians 2. [23:13] |
| What is justification? | God infuses righteousness into the sinner, who then gains a right standing on the basis of that change. [24:01] | The sinner trusts the alien righteousness of Christ alone, so justification rests on the Savior and not on something in the sinner. [24:01] |
| What happens to sins after baptism? | Confession to a priest, penance, time in purgatory, and indulgences drawing on a treasury of excess merit from the martyrs held by the Bishop of Rome. [24:58] [25:43] | The Reformers rejected indulgences, confession to priests, penances, the treasury of merit, and purgatory. Luther concluded that indulgences were contrary to Scripture. [19:27] [12:04] |
The Three Pillars of the Reformation
Bahnsen distills the Reformers’ protests into three points. [20:16] The table gives what each one affirms and the error Bahnsen says it answered.
| Pillar | What Bahnsen says it affirms | The error it answered |
|---|---|---|
| Sola gratia | Only the grace of God gives hope of salvation. Good works earn no eternal life by intrinsic merit, and salvation rests on God’s grace embraced in faith, which is itself his gift. [20:16] [21:10] [32:54] | Rome’s merit system, its infused righteousness, and its penance and indulgences. [24:01] [25:43] |
| Sola scriptura | Only Scripture is authoritative for telling us God’s will, and nothing may be added to God’s word. [20:16] [27:55] | Raising church tradition and the voice of the Pope to a par with Scripture, so that the church became the infallible interpreter. [26:39] [27:19] |
| Priesthood of all believers | All God’s people are priests with access to God through the one mediator, Christ. There is no sacred and secular distinction, and every believer has the right and the duty to interpret Scripture. [30:43] [31:53] | A holy priesthood set apart from the layman, with the priest as mediator of grace through the sacraments and of the knowledge of God through the Bible. Bahnsen notes that the Bible was placed on the index of books laymen could not read. [29:24] [29:50] [30:17] |
Bahnsen presents the three as a chain: the Reformation had to drive home sola gratia, back it up with sola scriptura, and back that up with the priesthood of every believer. [32:24]
Then and Now: Where Bahnsen Says the Reformation Is Dying
Bahnsen’s history serves his closing challenge. This table pairs what he says about Rome and the sixteenth century with what he says about the present. He draws the comparisons himself in the rows on little popes and on indulgences. The other pairings are this guide’s grouping of material he treats in separate places.
| Then | Now |
|---|---|
| Rome’s merit system placed salvation partly on human works. [24:01] | A works-righteousness view runs through the culture: the idea that being good enough will get you into heaven. [35:31] |
| Rome made the priest a mediator of the knowledge of God through the Bible and kept the Bible from laymen. [29:50] [30:17] | Believers fail to study Scripture seriously and depend on a favored teacher or elder to mediate the truth. Bahnsen also says not to put preachers on a pedestal. [39:08] [31:23] |
| The Pope claimed supremacy over the church. [31:53] | Independent churches are governed in practice by little popes, all in the name of opposing the big pope of Rome. [37:54] |
| Rome sold indulgences, and Luther said they encouraged cheap grace. [12:04] | Bahnsen says Rome has its indulgences and Protestants have theirs, when we think we can be easily forgiven without a changed life. [39:48] |
| Rome set the holy priesthood apart from the mundane layman. [29:24] | Christians separate the religious things they do from the secular things, though Bahnsen says all callings are holy callings. [39:48] [30:43] |
| Justification was based on righteousness infused in the sinner. [24:01] | Church statements of faith say justification is on the basis of our faith, and Arminian churches add a free decision to Christ’s work. Bahnsen says justification is by grace through faith, not based on faith. [36:27] [37:24] |
| The Reformers protested Rome’s teaching as the whole of Christianity at stake. [19:27] [20:16] | Ecumenical forces soften the antithesis with Rome, which Bahnsen says has not essentially changed. [18:52] [34:25] [34:59] |
Full Transcript
[00:00] I won’t be preaching in the dark today, even if it isn’t as easy to see from over here. In the year in which I was growing up in the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, which is one of many churches known as a Reformed Church, it was often the case that at the end of October, the Lord’s Day preceding the 31st of the month, we would have a Reformation sermon or address that was not because we honor the Reformation in and of itself, because the Reformation itself honored the purity of the gospel. And we celebrated that fact.
[00:35] And though I don’t see many churches doing that as often today, I would like to, in some small measure, renew that tradition. I think it’s a good one. As I address you this afternoon on the need for continuing Reformation in the church, and I’d like you to turn in your Bibles to Romans, the first chapter, where we’ll read the first 17 verses as our text. Romans chapter 1, verses 1 to 17.
[00:59] Paul, a servant, separated unto the gospel of God, which he promised afore through his prophets in the holy scriptures, concerning his son, who was born in the seed of David, according to the flesh, who was declared to be son of God with power, according to the spirit of holiness, by the resurrection from the dead, even Jesus Christ our Lord, through whom we received grace and a power of God.
[01:25] apostleship unto obedience of faith among all the nations for his name’s sake, among whom are ye also called to be Jesus Christ to all that are in Rome, beloved of God, called to be saints, grace to you and peace from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ. First, I thank my God through Jesus Christ for you all that your faith is proclaimed throughout the whole world. For God is my witness whom I serve in my spirit in the gospel of his Son, how unceasingly I make mention of you, always in my prayers, making request, if by any means now at length I may be prospered by the will of God to come unto you.
[02:09] For I long to see you, that I may impart unto you some spiritual gift to the end ye may be established. That is, that I with you may be comforted in you, each of us, by the other’s faith, both yours and mine. For I would not have you ignorant, brethren, that oftentimes I purposed to come unto you, and was hindered heretofore, that I might have some fruit in you also, even as in the rest of the Gentiles.
[02:35] I am a debtor both to Greeks and to barbarians, both to the wise and to the foolish. So, as much as is in me, I am ready to preach the gospel to you also that are in Rome.
[02:47] For I’m not ashamed of the gospel, for it is the power of God unto salvation to everyone that believes, to the Jew first and also to the Greek. For therein is revealed a righteousness of God from faith unto faith. As it stands written, the righteous shall live by faith. And thus far the reading of God’s word. I chose this text because I suppose many of you already know this was the text that Martin Luther said as he struggled with his own sin and the weight of his failure to achieve peace with God, that when he was reading one day in the castle, it finally like a light from heaven dawned upon him, that the problem was that he was struggling to be right with God in his own effort and to do what the church had prescribed rather than to trust the merit of the Lord Jesus Christ. And as that verse, the quotation from Habakkuk, it came to him that the just shall live by faith. He finally understood the gospel. He finally understood what it was to have good news from God instead of the very bad news that he’d been living under. What do we mean by the Reformation? Why do we speak of the Reformation and why do we call our churches reformed churches?
[04:04] Well, I suppose it would be good to go back past the 1500s, much, much further back to the days of the New Testament, even back beyond that to the days of the Old Testament, to remind ourselves that the church, God’s people, has always been in need of reform. Reform is something that is constantly called for as we are the people of God in this world wish to serve him with greater consistency and obedience.
[04:32] Even as far back as the law of God, in the Mosaic law, we see that God prescribes certain times of covenant renewal and reformation for his people every seven years, and especially in the Jubilee 50th year. The people were to be renewed in their faith and to remember God’s word and to reform their ways.
[04:54] We read in the Old Testament the story of Josiah’s reform of the temple as when the temple is being cleaned, they come across a book of the law. I know this is hard for us to imagine in our day where Bibles are plentiful, but they actually came across a copy, the book of Deuteronomy, the book of the covenant apparently, and there realized what it is that God had wanted from them and how they needed to change their ways and the subsequent war on idolatry that arose from Josiah’s recovery of the law. We read of Malachi, the prophet, the last prophet of the Old Testament, calling the people of God, to reformation, God’s declaration that he would purify his people and purify the temple.
[05:37] Come to the New Testament, we look at Paul’s correction of the Corinthian church. The Corinthian church had so many problems in it, doctrinal, ethical, interpersonal, that I think we would be inclined today to suggest that it was maybe not a church of Christ at all. And yet Paul called upon the Corinthians as saints of God and corrected their errors and called for reformation in their midst. We think of John’s letter, actually Jesus’ letters through John to the seven churches of Asia Minor in Revelation 2 and 3, and the constant refrain there is the call to repentance and to change and to obedience before God, that the ways of the church would be reformed, that Christ would be honored as the Lord of the church. So throughout covenant history, from beginning to end, you can see the appropriateness of what has become the motto of the Reformation churches. Reformation churches are called Reformed because they are Reformed and always reforming. They have been changed by God, they have been purified, they have been Reformed, and yet the call for greater Reformation is always there. The Reformed churches are those which have arisen at Reformation, an event that took place, a series of events, in the 16th century, especially in northern Europe.
[06:58] The Reformed churches are particularly the Calvinistic branch of the churches that come out of the Protestant Reformation. What we see in the Protestant Reformation is nothing less than the dramatic, biblical revival of God’s work in the 16th century. The Reformation, in a sense, began on All Souls Day, actually the eve of All Souls Day, which comes to us in English translation as Halloween, Hallow’s Eve, October 31st in the year 1517.
[07:30] It was on that day that Martin Luther, who was presently a professor of biblical studies at the newly established University of Wittenberg in Germany, it was on that day that he announced a disputation on indulgences, stating his argument for this disputation and what we call 95 theses. I’m afraid that the 95 theses had taken on a life of their own.
[07:56] it’s really kind of a literary metaphor anymore, but we must lose sight of what those theses were all about. Martin Luther was not acting defiantly when he nailed the theses to the door of the castle church. That would have been nice. I mean, it makes for a great movie and it really serves our souls, but Luther was doing nothing out of the ordinary. In that day, it was the common practice among academics to debate with each other, and they would state the subject of a debate and what their position was in the form of theses. Luther had 95, it turned out. It wasn’t prescribed that you had to have 95. But he had 95 theses on indulgences that he said, I stand prepared and ready to debate. And he nailed those to the castle church door on the 31st of October in the year 1517. Those theses were very academic in character, if you read them. They were not excited in tone, but they did, as it turns out. They did touch the very nerve of Roman Catholic theology. Within two weeks of Luther doing that, every religious center in Europe was stirring with agitation because they marveled, you must look at the significance of it, they marveled that an obscure Augustinian monk, and he was obscure, and he was at an obscure university, that an obscure man like Luther had challenged the holy trade of the Pope himself.
[09:29] But of course, the 95 Theses were not at all intended by Luther as a call to Reformation. Not at that point, they weren’t. They were simply the proposal of a university professor to discuss the theology of indulgences in light of the errors and the abuses which had grown up over the centuries in connection with them. What was an indulgence? An indulgence was the release of a sinner from the penance that was necessary to keep him out of purgatory, or to release him for some period of time from purgatory.
[10:05] Remember that a priest would impose penance on the people, and when that penance was performed, the penance would diminish your time in purgatory. Medieval Christians had very little fear of hell, interestingly enough, because they believed that if they died forgiven and blessed by a Roman Catholic priest, they would be guaranteed access to heaven no matter what, because the key to heaven was held by the church, and the pope in particular, and so they would escape everlasting damnation. However, there were those post-baptismal sins of theirs that would bring a temporal penalty from God and which had to be cleansed away. Justice had to be performed before they could then enter into heaven.
[10:54] These penalties for their post-baptismal sins were imposed and meted out by the priests of the church, unremitted over their lifetime and would store up for them a period of time of punishment in purgatory. The details of the punishments of purgatory were vividly portrayed by the church. We see some rendition of that in Dante’s The Inferno and Purgatorio and so forth. Purgatory was a dreaded place, but at least it wasn’t going to be hell forever. And thus arose the sale of indulgences, a diminishing of your time in purgatory, if you were willing to purchase from the Pope the pardon that he would extend. To give you an example of what this meant, pilgrims who would make a trip to the relics of the castle church in Wittenberg, that’s where Luther nailed his theses, if you came to the relics of that church, you were reckoned to have earned a remission from purgatory for 1,902,202 years and 70 days.
[12:04] I’m not sure how they figured that out. The sale of indulgences to finance pet projects by the Pope had grown into an outrageous scandal, as Luther saw it. And upon reflection, and particularly upon biblical investigation, Luther came to be convinced that the sale of these indulgences was actually contrary to scripture, and contrary to reason, and certainly contrary to church tradition. Indeed, as Luther said, indulgences encouraged a notion of what we would call cheap grace, whereby a man could continue in his sin, unmindful of Christ and God’s forgiveness, if he just planned simply to buy his way out of the suffering of purgatory by his good works and the purchase of an indulgence. Now, by challenging indulgences, Luther was actually, though I think he only faintly understood it at the time, challenging of salvation as was advocated by the Romanist church. Most immediately, he was challenging the authority of the Pope, of course, especially in the Pope’s alleged prerogative to shut the gate of hell and open the gate of heaven to anyone he wished. Now both the official hierarchy of the church and the everyday religious practice of European Christians were simultaneously being undermined by that very bold stroke of Luther’s then and as it turns out the Christian church would never be the same and Western Europe would never be the same. And so Luther had disputations, first within his Augustinian order. One was held in Heidelberg in the year 1518. And then he had disputations with papal authorities, one in Augsburg in 1518, another in Leipzig in 1519. His published accounts of these disputations, these debates with Rome, were spread about so people could judge for themselves, not on the basis of what some men had told them. Luther placed, you see, the ordinary Christian man and woman on their own theological feet, trusting that every one of them was a priest before God and was able to find the truth in reading the Bible for themselves. And it’s for that reason that Luther’s followers multiplied. If he had not believed that, if he had not put the Bible into the hands of the ordinary man, then he would have been shut out and blackballed by the church forever. Finally, in the year 1520, Luther was excommunicated by the Pope.
[14:36] And then at the Diet of Worms in 1521, he was outlawed by the Emperor Charles V. And it was there that Luther, being called upon to recant his views and establish his freedom within the kingdom, asked for another day to consider, and then came back the next morning and offered a renowned answer that I’m sure you’ve heard, but is stirring every time we consider it.
[15:00] Luther stood before the Diet, and the Imperial Majesty and the Lordships gathered there, and he says, you have demanded of me a simple answer. Here it is, plain and unvarnished. Unless I am convinced of error by the testimony of Scripture, or by manifest reason, since I put no trust in the unsupported authority of the Pope or of councils, since it is plain that they have often erred and often contradicted themselves.
[15:28] I stand convicted by the scriptures to which I have appealed and my conscience is taken captive by the word of God. I cannot and I will not recant anything, for to act against our conscience is neither safe for us nor open to us. On this I take my stand.
[15:46] I can’t do other. God help me. Amen. Luther’s dramatic stand against both the Pope and the Emperor now fired the imagination of Europe. His sole support, remember, was the written Word of God in Scripture. His only hope, he says, is his faith in Jesus Christ as his Savior. Over the next 25 years, Luther published book after book written in vivid German for the ordinary Christian reader. He translated the Bible into German so that it would be accessible to his fellow men, thus enabling them to see for themselves the truth of his arguments.
[16:26] In the year 1529, at the Diet of Spire, Emperor Charles V attempted to curb the Lutheran movement by force now. However, it was at that point that some of the princes of Germany, the German states, stood up to take protest. And from that time on, those who stood against the Roman Catholic Church were designated those who protest, Protestants. The movement which had attempted to reform Catholicism from within was now separated off from the church and became known as the Protestant Reformation. It fostered a reformed church that would be true to the scriptures, true to the doctrines of God’s saving grace. That movement split Christian Europe in two. It gave rise to churches known as evangelical or Protestant, and in particular, three traditions have arisen out of that movement in Germany. We have the Lutheran tradition, found particularly in that day in Germany and Scandinavia. The Calvinist tradition, found in the churches of Switzerland, France, Holland and Scotland, and then eventually the Anglican Church in England. Because the Protestant outlook encompassed a reformed view of knowledge and authority, how we know what we do, a reformed view of God’s saving work with man, a reformed view of man’s place within God’s kingdom, that movement brought not just the change in the church, but lasting social, political, and economic changes in Europe as well.
[17:59] For you see, the Reformation brought an entirely new and whole world and life view for the Christian. The heart of that world and life view, the heart of that outlook, was primarily the rediscovery of the gospel of God’s saving work in Christ, a truth which could liberate the heart from any theology that obscured God’s grace and from any practice or any custom that tended to corrupt it. It was in the Protestant Reformation then, nearly 500 years ago, that God began reviving his work in Northern Europe.
[18:36] Why was the Protestant Reformation necessary? We have to ask that, especially in our day, because, one, we’re so far distant from it, nearly 500 years, that we begin to wonder whether anything that took place that long ago could really be that important to us.
[18:52] We need to ask the question why it was necessary, because in our day and age, to my shock, to the saddening of my heart, there are people who are talking now as though some kind of ecumenical relationship with Romanism might be perfectly acceptable. Haven’t Catholics learned their lesson? Isn’t the Pope a nice guy? There are those who are actually promoting in our day and age, as you know from the reading of your last issue of Antithesis. There are those who are promoting a return from the Protestant faith back into the Roman Catholic communion.
[19:27] Why was the Protestant Reformation necessary and is it necessary today? It absolutely is. You see, the Protestants had more than a minor disagreement on some obscure point or two with the Romanist church. Just listen to what the Protestants rejected. They rejected indulgences. They rejected relics, rosaries, holy water, prayer for the dead, sacraments that were not taught in the Bible, transubstantiation, worship by superstitious rites and in an unknown language, the celibacy of priests, the confession made to priests, penances, the treasury of merit, purgatory, works of supererogation, the mediation of Mary, the mediation of the saints, the authority of the Pope, and the merit of good works.
[20:16] That’s not an obscure point or two. That’s the whole of Christianity. What you have between Romanism and Protestantism is two different religions proclaiming the name Christian. And what’s fraudulent? I think three major points can be distilled from the protests that were issued by the Reformers. One, they insisted upon what they said in Latin, sola gratia, only the grace of God gives us hope for salvation. Two, sola scriptura, only scripture is authoritative for telling us God’s will. And three, the priesthood of all believers, sola gratia, sola scriptura, and the priesthood of all believers. Those major biblical themes made the Protestant Reformation a necessity.
[21:10] To understand this, let me take you a step back and explain what the Roman Catholic view of justification is. The Bible teaches us, contrary to Rome, that even the good works of believers in Jesus Christ do not earn eternal life by any intrinsic merit in them. I hope you understand that. I hope that when you pray to God, that you ask him to accept you not only forgiving, but to accept your good works for the sake of Jesus Christ, because there is nothing inherently meritorious about any good that you do, even as a regenerated believer in Jesus Christ. Romanism didn’t teach that. Romanism taught that there is what was called a congruous merit, a favorable quality that attended the good works done by unbelievers even before their conversion. And this congruous merit moves the heart of God to bestow divine grace upon the unbeliever because the unbeliever is trying to do good.
[22:16] John Calvin was horrified by that teaching. There are no good works done by the unregenerate. Do we understand that? The Bible couldn’t be clearer. Hebrews 11, 6, without faith, it is impossible to please him. Romans 8.8, they that are in the flesh cannot please God. There is no favorable quality attending the work of unbelievers. Romanism went beyond that, though. It further taught the doctrine of condign merit, congruous merit for unbelievers, condign merit for believers. Condign merit is the value which attaches to the good works done after your conversion with the help of grace, but which, by their proper value, would entitle the believer to eternal life, according to Rome. However, the blood of Christ is necessary to be added to that.
[23:13] Nevertheless, there is a condign and genuine merit in what they do. John Calvin said there is no deserving merit, even in the works of the regenerate. Listen to Romans 6, 23. The wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord. Paul says in Ephesians 2, for by grace are ye saved through faith, and that not of yourselves, it is the gift of God, not of works, lest any man should boast. As regenerate believers receiving the gift of faith, we have nothing to boast in our works. You see, Rome was teaching what we now call synergism. God and the sinner work together to bring about salvation.
[24:01] The merit of works was introduced into man’s justification before God rather than having the sinner trust the alien righteousness of Christ and him alone. Indeed, Rome went so far as to define justification as God’s infusing the sinner, subjectively transforming the sinner with righteousness. And on the basis of that infused change in the sinner, he would gain a right standing with God. In which case, justification is based upon something in me rather than entirely upon my Savior whom I trust. In short, Rome taught men that they save themselves by utilizing the merit of Christ, but that they must merit of Christ. They must add to the work of Christ in order to be saved.
[24:58] Well, that leads then to Rome’s view of salvation through confession of sin and the satisfaction of our own sins. Romanist theology teaches that saving repentance involves confession of all of our sins to a priest who, in God’s place, assigns works of penance to us that can satisfy the justice of God. In baptism, the eternal penalty of our sins was removed, but the temporal penalties of our sins for which we will suffer in purgatory after baptism are merely lessened by the work of Christ. And only through the help of penance, works that we do adding to the cross of Christ can we escape those temporal penalties.
[25:43] Then we can reach what was called second pardon from God, post-baptismal pardon, based on our own good works. Indulgences would supply what we fail to earn by ourselves, because indulgences distribute the merit of faith and the merit of the martyrs to us. Because, you see, the martyrs in Christ had good works of supererogation. They went over and above what they needed to do. And that meant that there was a treasury, an excess merit held, I don’t know why, but held by the Bishop of Rome. And he had the right then, as it were, holding this bank account, this treasury, to distribute it to anyone he wished to do so. The excess merit built up by the works of supererogation could then ease your time in purgatory if, of course, you paid the appropriate price for the indulgence.
[26:39] How could you defend such views? I want you to see that the errors of Rome are all apiece. They are all tied together. The only way Rome could defend such blasphemous ideas was to appeal to the authority of tradition and to make the voice of the Pope on a par with the Scripture. Then, of course, they’d be able to answer the Reformers who appealed to Scripture against them. The Roman Catholic Church found it necessary to exalt church to the position of an infallible interpreter of the Bible, And thus being the infallible interpreter in actual practice, church tradition became on a par with Scripture.
[27:19] He lorded it over God’s own word. Interestingly, Paul the Apostle in Galatians 1, those of you who have been at Bible study recently know this, Paul the Apostle declared that the views taught by the Roman church were accursed of God, even if taught by an angel from God. If an angel appears and teaches these things, let him be set apart for destruction, Paul said. And so Rome, not wishing to come under that condemnation, had to appeal to something else. Church tradition and the authority of an infallible pope.
[27:55] Christ himself in Matthew 15 condemned human tradition that supplants the word of God. Quoting Isaiah to the effect, Honor me with their lips, but their hearts are far from me. For by their traditions, they undo the very word of God. By contrast, the reformers looked to scripture and scripture alone, sola scriptura, for their theological authority. They were quick to distinguish between the wisdom of men and the wisdom of God, as Paul does in 1 Corinthians 2. They were not willing to have anything added to God’s word, even as Moses declared in Deuteronomy chapter 4. They were very mindful of the warning of Jeremiah 23, be careful of the prophets who speak a vision out of their own heart and not from the word of the Lord. They knew, as Paul said, that their faiths should not stand in the wisdom of men, but in the power of God.
[28:55] You see, to understand and really appreciate, as I hope you do today, the Protestant Reformation, You need to see that they didn’t seek theological innovation. They didn’t seek theological renovation. They only wanted a return to the purity of biblical teaching. And so Rome was in a very awkward place, having taught things contrary to the Bible, and then having to prop up their authority with an infallible pope in the traditions of the church.
[29:24] The Roman church had to now draw a sharp distinction between the holy priesthood and the mundane layman. Because at this point, Luther and his followers could put the Bible in the hands of men and say, read for yourself, is what they’re saying true about tradition? Is what they’re saying true about the Pope? Is what they are saying true about justification and the grace of God and the work of Jesus Christ in the gospel?
[29:50] And at that point, the Roman Church, you’re not going to believe this, but it is true, my friends. The Roman Catholic Church put the Bible on the index of books that laymen were not allowed to read. Because the Bible was subject to misinterpretation and error, Luther and his followers show us, no layman should read the Bible, but should rather hear it interpreted infallibly by a priest who would represent the voice of Mother Rome.
[30:17] The priest became not only a mediator of God’s grace through the sacraments, but a mediator of the knowledge of God through the Bible. And if the layman would not hear the priest and not receive the sacrament of the priest, the layman would not stand a chance before God. Obviously, that placed the priest in a privileged position. And obviously, it opened the door to tyranny over the souls of men.
[30:43] You’ll read in 1 Peter 2, a quotation from Exodus 19, that tells us that all of God’s people are priests. All of God’s people go before the very throne of God through their one mediator, the Lord Jesus Christ. That all of God’s people stand on a par beforehand, regardless of their vocation in life. There is no sacred and secular distinction to be observed according to the Protestant Reformation. We are all priests, and all of our callings are holy callings, and all of our work is pursued for the sake of the kingdom of God and obedience to the Lord Jesus Christ, our king.
[31:23] And that’s why all occupations are equal. The preacher is not in a closer position to the truth or a closer position to God just because he has seminary training, just because he stands in the pulpit. And I hope you remember that today. Don’t put your preachers on a pedestal. Don’t. They are only servants, and you are servants, and servants of the same Lord and through the same agency of direction in the Scripture.
[31:53] Every believer has the right and the duty to interpret the Scriptures for himself. All members of the Church of Jesus Christ participate in the ministry and the government of the church. Though there is a divine right of church government, It is not one imposed on the people, but a ride with the people. And the Pope, to put it very bluntly, is not supreme over anyone. He’s not supreme even over the church in Rome, much less supreme over all of Christendom.
[32:24] And so the Protestant Reformation had to drive home sola gratia, had to back that up with sola scriptura, and back that up with the priesthood of every believer. I guess you can tell I’m pretty excited about the Reformation. If I didn’t believe these truths, and I don’t say this to have some kind of arch drama for you today. I mean it from the heart. If I didn’t believe these things, I wouldn’t be a preacher. I wouldn’t be a pastor. These things make all the difference in the world.
[32:54] Though I did not have an experience like unto Luther’s. The fact is, my heart goes out as I read about Luther’s experience of knowing the emancipating effect of the gospel. To know that my salvation does not depend upon the meaty man, not upon the sacraments of the church, not upon my confession to a priest, not upon my own merit and good works, but only based on the grace of God that I embrace in faith, which itself is a gift from him. And it’s just because I so love the precious truths of the Reformation and what that Reformation means that today I’d like to end by telling you I’m afraid the Reformation may die.
[33:39] You say, well, when did the Reformation die, Pastor Bahnsen? Well, in one sense, the Reformation died almost immediately. It died in some churches of the Radical Reformation, churches that we now call Anabaptist in their tradition. For you see, in the Anabaptist sects of Europe, there was a denial of God’s covenant grace, and that’s why they would not baptize infants. There was a denial of the divine right of church government. There was an affirmation of a mystical view of piety contrary to obedience to the law of God. There was a religion of the world rather than the claim that the world belonged to Christ and needed to be transformed for his glory. In that sense, the Reformation was blunted and put aside almost immediately.
[34:25] But the Reformation didn’t just die in the Anabaptist sects, which has continued with us today in various communions and denominations. I’m afraid that the Reformation is dying daily in our day, when the ecumenical movement and other forces like unto it wish to soften the antithesis with Rome today. I want to assure you, it’s not my pugnacious debating nature that makes me say we must exalt that antithesis and guard it. It’s my love for the Lord Jesus Christ and the purity of his word.
[34:59] Rome has not essentially changed. Rome declared that what it said at the time of the Reformation was infallible and could not change. Declared it to be irreformable through. Rome has not changed. The precious truths of God’s word are still worth upholding, even at the cost of unity, even at the cost of being considered troublemakers in the religious world. We need to guard the antithesis against the destructive error of Rome.
[35:31] I think the Reformation is dying in our culture more generally, too. we have enjoyed the fruits of the Protestant Reformation, especially as the Puritans from England came over and in New England began this country with a Calvinistic, covenantal understanding of Christianity. Christianity and the Protestant Reformation are dying in our culture as we see what is really a works righteousness understanding of how to be right with God promulgated throughout our culture. You know, you don’t have to be a theologian. You don’t have to speak in theological jargon to be caught up in the heresy of works righteousness. How can we be thought to live in a Protestant culture where the general populace all around us has essentially a pagan view of God and a pagan understanding of salvation that if I’m just good enough, when I get to heaven, God will let me in.
[36:27] the reformation dies in the softening of antithesis to rome it dies in our general culture as people don’t understand the need for god’s grace but it dies in our churches too how often have i seen local protestant churches have their little statement of faith and there you will find this deadly remark that justification is on the basis of our faith justification is not on the basis of our faith do you understand the difference justification is on the basis of god’s grace in christ it’s based on the righteousness of jesus christ which we apprehend by faith it is by grace through faith not based on faith if we’re based on faith which for all of us of course is inconsistent is stained by sin if it was upon anything in ourselves, even our own faith, we would not be right with God.
[37:24] How often have I heard Arminian brothers in the Lord make the huge mistake of thinking that a decision, a free decision made for Jesus, can be added to his work and turn it into something effective in their lives, as though we can add to the merit of Christ by our decision to follow him. No, the Reformation dies, don’t you see? Not just in Romanism, but in the Arminian churches of our land as well. The Reformation dies in our own churches.
[37:54] When church tradition and when the comfort that we can get from messages takes the place of exegesis and the interpretation of God’s Word, when we think of worship services as aimed to make us feel good rather than to bring us into the holy presence of God, to praise him and to hear his word declared for our Reformation. The Reformation dies in our churches when independent churches grow up, which are governed in practice by little popes, all in the name of opposing the big pope of Rome. They all have their own little popes, rather than the declared, ordained government of the church, as we find in the New Testament.
[38:37] The Reformation dies in our churches when there’s a lack of church discipline, when there is no encouragement of personal holiness, when the whole idea is to make us think everything’s all right with God if we just go through the rituals of the church and show up on time. The Reformation has died or is dying in our personal lives, too. It’s not just in history, not just in our general culture, not just in our churches, but it dies in us.
[39:08] When there is an us individually, and I speak to each and every one of you sitting, and the audience now, and to myself, when there is a failure on our part to study the Scripture seriously, and we depend for our religious knowledge upon our past some favored teacher or some elder to mediate the truth to us. What kind of reformed churches allow that to take place? The Reformation dies in our individual lives and our failure to act as priests before God, because we will not consecrate our every effort for the advance of God’s kingdom.
[39:48] When we continue to think of the religious things we do and then the secular things we do, rather than seeing us as children belonging to a kingdom that encompasses everything, we are part and parcel of the family of God, and God owns everything, and therefore everything is done to his service. The Reformation dies in our lives when we indulge in cheap grace. Rome has its indulgences and Protestants have theirs. When we indulge in cheap grace, thinking we can be easily forgiven and we don’t need to show a changed life and a renewed life before God.
[40:26] This Reformation Day, I’m going to ask you to join me in praying that God will revive his work again. lest the precious truths of the Protestant Reformation die out in our own experience, in our own churches, our individual lives. Let’s pray.
[40:42] God, we thank you for the purity of the gospel. We thank you that you’ve sent us good news, not bad news. We thank you that somehow, by your grace, marvelously and amazingly, You have been willing to extend pardon and salvation to us with the work of Christ your Son.
[41:02] And we do embrace that by faith, without anything in our hand to offer to you, without any hope of pardon for any accomplishment or achievement or good that we have done, without any hope of following a ritual that will make us right with you, but simply trusting your promises, simply laying hold of your sin, simply making our only hope your loving kindness, And we pray for the sake of Christ and his honor and for the comfort of the good news that has come to us, that you would fire our hearts with a desire to defend these precious truths against every encroachment.
[41:38] We pray that you would not allow some human mediator to get in the way of our knowledge of your promise and our testing of every teaching that comes to us by the holiness of your word. We pray that you would not allow us to soften the antithesis with those fellowships that declare that there is some merit in the church to be distributed by human priests. We pray that you would fire our souls with righteous indignation against those, even angels from heaven, that might declare that anything could be added to the merit of our Savior Jesus Christ.
[42:13] We pray that we would not simply look without for the need of continuing reformation, but today you would help us to look within, that we would become true students of your word day by day, that we would truly act as priests in this world, representing you before men and performing holy service in all of our vocations before you. We pray that you would bring about true reformation in our lives, that we would not simply think we can appeal to your mercy and not have to turn from our sins. God, we do pray that you would revive your work in our day for the sake of Christ, in whose name we pray. Amen. Amen.
0:00 Opening Remarks…The Need For Continuing Reformation In The Church…Rom1:1-17
3:09 Martin Luther’s Struggle With Sin & To Be Right With GOD In His Own Effort…Finally, He Understood To Trust The Merit Of JESUS CHRIST ALONE (Rom1:1-17)
3:56 (A) What Do We Mean By THE REFORMATION? (B) Why Do We Speak Of THE REFORMATION? (C) Why Do We Call Our Churches REFORMED CHURCHES?
4:05 (A) Throughout Church History To The New & Old Testaments, Remind Us That The Church Is Always In Need Of Reform To Serve GOD With Greater Consistency & Obedience
4:32 (B) The Mosaic Law, Times Of Covenant Renewal & REFORMATION (Every Seven Years, Jubilee The Fiftieth Year)…Josiah’s REFORM…Malachi…Paul & The Corinthian Church…JESUS’ Letters Through John To The Seven Churches In Rev2&3…
6:30 (C) Reformation Churches Are Called “REFORMED” Because They Have Been Purified, Yet The Call For Greater Reformation (Consistency & Obedience To GOD) Is Always There
6:46 The REFORMED CHURCHES, Are Those That Began During The 16th Century Especially In Northern Europe, & Are Particularly The Calvinistic Branch Of The Churches That Come Out Of THE PROTESTANT REFORMATION
7:06 THE PROTESTANT REFORMATION: The Traumatic Biblical Revival Of GOD’s Work In The 16th Century…Began (In A Sense) On The Eve Of, ALL SOULS DAY aka HALLOWEEN October 31, 1517…Martin Luther Announces A Disputation On Indulgences…95 Thesis
7:47 95 Thesis (A Closer Look)…An Obscure Man Challenges The Pope…Reformation By Happenstance
9:50 What Was An Indulgence? A Release Of A Sinner From The Penance That Was Necessary To Keep Him Out Of Purgatory…Or, To Release Him For Some Period Of Time From Purgatory…GLB Expands…(Medieval View Of HELL)
11:25 eg, What Indulgences Meant…Martin Luther Called It Out As, “CHEAP GRACE”
13:35 Luther’s Disputations At Heidelberg 1518; Augsburg 1518; Leipzig 1519…Luther’s Published Accounts Of These Disputations Empowered The Common Person To Know What Scripture Actually Taught…1520 Luther Was Excommunicated By The Pope…1521 At The Diet (Assembly) Of Worms, Luther Was Outlawed By The Emperor Charles The 5th
14:43 Luther’s Famous Words At The Diet Of Worms, “Here I Stand. I Can Do No Other. GOD Help Me.” …His Only Hope Is In CHRIST ALONE
16:08 Luther’s Publications To Help The Common Person Understand THE WORD Of GOD…1529 At The Diet Of Speyer Emperor Charles The 5th Opposes Luther’s Movement By Force
16:34 German Princes (States) PROTEST Emperor Charles. And From That Time On Those Who Stood Against The Roman Catholic Church Were Designated Those Who PROTEST aka PROTESTANTS
16:49 THE PROTESTANT REFORMATION…Three Traditions: Lutheran; Calvinist; Anglican…GLB Expands About The Impact Of TPR On Society
18:36 Why Was TPR Necessary; And, Is It Necessary Today? Absolutely Yes! GLB Expands On The Major Issues Of Contention Between Protestantism & Romanism…
20:33 THREE MAJOR POINTS DISTILLED FROM THE PROTEST THAT WERE ISSUED BY THE REFORMERS:
20:39 1) SOLA GRATIA (GRACE ALONE)
20:48 2) SOLA SCRIPTURA (SCRIPTURA ALONE)
20:55 3) THE PRIESTHOOD OF ALL BELIEVERS
21:11 The Roman Catholic View Of Justification (Congruous Merit & Condign Merit)…Contradicts Heb11:6; Rom 8:8; Rom 6:23; Eph 2:4
23:51 Romanism Teaches Synergism (Justification Is Dependent On Some Form Of Work/Merit By The Pupil Rather Than Fully Relying On JESUS’ Work Of THE CROSS)…GLB Expands…Confession; Penance; Indulgences; Excess Merit; Treasury Of Merit; Supererogation; Post Baptismal Pardon
26:39 The Exaltation Of Church Tradition & Infallible Interpreter (The Pope) To Justify Blasphemous Doctrines & Abuse Of The Scriptures…GLB Expands With Galatians 1:8; Matthew 15:2; Isaiah 29:13
28:12 THE REFORMERS CONTRAST TO ROMANISM…They Didn’t Seek Theological Innovation, They Sought Theological Renovation
29:24 Rome’s Strategy Against Protestantism & Luther’s Efforts…The Exaltation Of The Priest
30:43 1Peter2 – ALL OF GOD’s PEOPLE ARE PRIESTS & GO BEFORE THE VERY THRONE OF GOD THROUGH ONE MEDIATOR: THE LORD JESUS CHRIST
31:23 All Occupations Are Equal…DO NOT EXALT THE PREACHER…We Are All SERVANTS OF GOD…Right & Duty Of All Members Of The Church…The Proper View Of Church Government
32:24 THESE THINGS MAKE ALL THE DIFFERENCE IN THE WORLD!
33:27 THE REFORMATION MAY DIE?!…Dies In The Softening Of Antithesis To Rome…In Our General Culture As People Don’t Understand The Need For GOD’s GRACE…In Our Churches (Deadly Misunderstanding About Faith & Grace)…Exalting Church Traditions & Men Within The Church…
38:56 GLB Expands To Our Personal Lives…Failure To Study The Scripture Seriously…To Perform Holy Service In All Our Vocations…Indulging In Cheap Grace
40:41 PRAYER
*Note: Source Audio Contained Glitches